Page 1 of 2

Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sat Sep 14, 2019 11:02 am
by Adam Xie
RFA

The Tonle Sap, the largest freshwater lake in Southeast Asia, is often described as “the heart of the Mekong.”
But seasonal floods have not yet raised the level of the lake to its normal monsoon-season size, Brian Eyler said in response to an email query.
The Tonle Sap would normally increase its level by four times during the monsoon season.

https://www.rfa.org/english/commentarie ... 55403.html

Sad...just sad

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sat Sep 14, 2019 9:01 pm
by DaveG
Fuckin hell, give it a chance, it's only just started raining properly here. :stir:

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sun Sep 15, 2019 1:20 am
by Kammekor
Last year flooding all around the country. This year not so many (yet). That’s called weather (as opposed to climate).

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sun Sep 15, 2019 2:21 am
by frank lee bent
Not only Mekong
https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-inter ... its-region

Recent reports of a rapid diminishment in the size of the glaciers that feed the great rivers of Asia, including the Mekong, have received wide coverage, not least because they are accompanied by striking visuals.

What is happening at the other end of the river in the Mekong Delta has garnered much less attention. But it may well be that the river’s vast and productive delta will be where the more immediate effects of changes to the Mekong will first become apparent. And for a country such as Vietnam, the Mekong Delta provides in excess of 50% of its agricultural GDP.


I was alerted to the latest information in a disturbing VOA report from earlier this year with its suggestion that the delta could disappear entirely by the end of the century. The report is largely based on research carried out at Utrecht University in the Netherlands which draws attention to the rapid subsidence and reduction in the size of the delta’s land area due to excessive pumping out of underlying water reserves. This is a process of great concern when the prospect of rising sea levels due to climate change is likely to accelerate the steady increase in saltwater intrusion that has been occurring for decades. (A particularly useful summary of the issue is published here.)

And the VOA account also draws attention to a point that has been of concern for close observers of the Mekong for some time: the blocking effect on the flow of sediment down the river as the result of the cascade of dams built by China on the river’s upper reaches.

To date seven 11 dams* have been built with more in prospect. There is universal agreement on the vital role played by the sediment flow down the river, but nowhere is it more important than in the Mekong Delta. The sediment contains critical nutrients that are spread of agricultural land during flood seasons as well as replacing loss of topsoil in those floods.

While there is some variation in the estimates of the size of the sediment flow down the Mekong before any dams were built, there is agreement that without any impediment the bulk of the sediment that flowed down the river originated in China. Estimates of the Chinese content of this flow has never been less than 80% of the total. Yet China in building its dams made no provision for the flushing of sediment from the dams’ reservoirs. Indeed, to the contrary, one of the factors behind the construction of its huge dam at Xiaowan was to the restrict the flow of sediment into the first two dams it completed at Manwan and Dachaoshan.

The gravity of the situation presented by the Utrecht research is highlighted by the observation of a senior Vietnamese official lamenting the already clear reduction in the delta’s surface area cited in the VOA report. Long known as the region of the Nine Dragons (“cuu long”) as a reflection of the nine mouths of the Mekong as it flows into the South China Sea, Bui Chi Buu, Director-General of the Institute for Agricultural Science for Southern Vietnam, speaks of the river’s mouths being reduced to seven while fearing that “in the future maybe we have four or five”.


* Update: in addition to the seven dams regularly cited as completed ­­– Manwan, Dachaosha, Xiaowan, Nuozhadu, Gongguoqi, Jinghon and Miaowei – recent research kindly transmitted to me by Bryan Eyler of the Stimson Center in Washington DC has identified four further dams in operation: Dahuaqiao, Huangdeng, Lidi and Wunonglor, all located on the upper reaches of the river, which is known as the Lancang in China.

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sun Sep 15, 2019 3:04 am
by SternAAlbifrons
frank lee bent wrote: Sun Sep 15, 2019 2:21 am
.... draws attention to a point that has been of concern for close observers of the Mekong for some time: the blocking effect on the flow of sediment down the river as the result of the cascade of dams built by China on the river’s upper reaches.

There is universal agreement on the vital role played by the sediment flow down the river, but nowhere is it more important than in the Mekong Delta. The sediment contains critical nutrients that are spread of agricultural land during flood seasons as well as replacing loss of topsoil in those floods.

... there is agreement that without any impediment the bulk of the sediment that flowed down the river originated in China. Estimates of the Chinese content of this flow has never been less than 80% of the total. Yet China in building its dams made no provision for the flushing of sediment from the dams’ reservoirs.

The gravity of the situation presented by the Utrecht research is highlighted by the observation of a senior Vietnamese official lamenting the already clear reduction in the delta’s surface area cited in the VOA report. Long known as the region of the Nine Dragons (“cuu long”) as a reflection of the nine mouths of the Mekong as it flows into the South China Sea
Thanks frank, important piece. I just wanted to reinforce it by underlining that key word - sediment sediment sediment.

Apart from the nutrients in the sediment, they are also a crucial element in the very existence of most of cambodia and the most productive part of southern vietnam.
I was really surprised when i recently discovered just how recently the whole 9 Dragons area was formed - purely from the sediment flow.

The Mekong dams are not only going to F*** the whole ecology of the system, they are also going to threaten the very geography that we live on. And soon.

PS, The Koh Kong dams are also having a catastrophic effect on the mangroves and coastline generally. Blocking both the crucial sediment itself - and the nutrients it contains.
The reduction in the coastal catch is going to match the evaporation of the Tonle Sap fishery.
The destruction of 70-80% of cambodia's protein supply has never been factored into any consideration of these dams.

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sun Sep 15, 2019 12:18 pm
by ExPenhMan
I was alerted to the latest information in a disturbing VOA report from earlier this year with its suggestion that the delta could disappear entirely by the end of the century. The report is largely based on research carried out at Utrecht University in the Netherlands which draws attention to the rapid subsidence and reduction in the size of the delta’s land area due to excessive pumping out of underlying water reserves. This is a process of great concern when the prospect of rising sea levels due to climate change is likely to accelerate the steady increase in saltwater intrusion that has been occurring for decades. (A particularly useful summary of the issue is published here.)

I would certainly give strong credence to this report since it's based on Dutch research. They know a thing or two about living in harmony with water resources. Alas, is anyone in power in China, Laos, Vietnam and Cambodia listening? Not bloody likely. Economic plundering, i.e., money, rules.

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sun Sep 15, 2019 12:22 pm
by Clutch Cargo
Alas, is anyone in power in China, Laos, Vietnam and Cambodia listening? Not bloody likely. Economic plundering, i.e., money, rules.

Self interest I suspect too..

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Sun Sep 15, 2019 5:39 pm
by Duncan
Can someone please explain to a simpleton like me what happens to the millions of cubic metre's of sediment that would normally flow down the Mekong, and for the next 20 or 30 years will now be settling trapped behind a dam wall .

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Mon Sep 23, 2019 7:53 pm
by CEOCambodiaNews
Cambodia’s lifeline threatened as Mekong recedes to historic low
Dams, low rainfall and changing climate blamed for decline in river's fortunes amid worries about crucial food supply.
By Al Jazeera -
September 23, 2019

Phnom Penh – As world leaders meet in New York from Monday to discuss the global challenge of climate change, thousands of kilometres away people in Cambodia are grappling with dramatic changes to the country’s ecosystem, including the lowest water levels in the crucially-important Mekong River ever recorded.

The United Nations Development Programme, which partners with the Cambodian government on climate, says the country is among the three most vulnerable areas in Asia.

“[Cambodia] is highly vulnerable due to a relatively low adaptive capacity,” said Nick Beresford, UNDP Cambodia’s Resident Representative.

In full: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/09/ ... 18567.html

Re: Despite Seasonal Floods Now, Experts See Risk of Mekong Drying Up

Posted: Tue Sep 24, 2019 5:35 am
by CEOCambodiaNews
COVERING CLIMATE NOW: Drought, poor rice harvest signs of climate change in Southeast Asia
THE ASAHI SHIMBUN
September 18, 2019
http://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/AJ201909180044.html
The Mekong River Commission, which groups the nations of Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam, said in July that the level of the river was the lowest on record. While flooding is normal for June and July, water levels for the four nations along the Mekong have dropped several meters below the average figure since 1961.

Moreover, rainfall has also been low, with only about 67 percent the monthly average rainfall for the period between 2006 and 2018.