Cambodia needs safer street designs
- Kung-fu Hillbilly
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4171
- Joined: Sat May 17, 2014 11:26 am
- Reputation: 4984
- Location: Behind you.
Cambodia needs safer street designs
by SES ARONSAKDA
July 12, 2022
If a passenger plane crashed and killed 162 people every month, there would be enormous public outrage, an intensive government investigation and a push to reform safety.
Yet similar casualty figures on Cambodia’s roads only garner condolences, tired explanations and redundant promises, never real change.
The national police reported 859 traffic accidents with 486 deaths from January through March. The cost of road traffic accidents was estimated to have cost Cambodia $466.8 million in 2019 alone, equivalent to 1.7% of the country’s annual GDP earnings, according to a report by the National Road Safety Committee (NRSC) and the United Nations Development Programme.
NRSC Secretary-General Min Manavy urged road users to respect the traffic laws, noting that 866 people involved in accidents involving motorbikes were helmetless.
Helmets and seatbelts only mitigate injuries, they do not prevent a vehicle careening down a street and causing injuries. Instead of blaming victims, Cambodia must enact a comprehensive overhaul to examine the true culprits of traffic accidents and make a radical policy shift to solve the issue.
The Ministry of Public Works and Transportation reported overspeeding accounted for 33% of the 1,619 accidents recorded nationwide in the first half of 2020. The other factors involved in the accidents included right-of-way (23%), incorrect lane use (14%), overtaking (10%) and incorrect turning (10%).
While careless drivers accounted for 90% of all traffic accidents in 2020, the reasons drivers speed and overtake on crowded roads, intersections or sharp turns is rarely discussed.
Asia Injury Prevention Foundation Director Kim Panga highlighted the issue of speed. In a Phnom Penh Post interview, he recommended amending speed limits in previously implemented sub-decrees, arguing that speeds in school areas should be limited to a maximum of 30 kph (18.6 mph) while the speed limit for passenger trucks should be lowered to a maximum of 50 kph (31 mph).
Traffic police throughout Cambodia have set up checkpoints and a new speed camera system in an attempt to correct the issue, but speed limit reform is a limited, top-down approach. Traffic police cannot be expected to set up checkpoints at every street corner, nor do speed cameras address the root causes of many accidents.
Better road design is the primary tool Cambodia should apply to address driver behaviour and road safety.
Road designs
Passive and proactive designs are little-known road engineering philosophies that could significantly change the conversation.
A passive design approach accounts for the worst-case scenarios: crashes and traffic congestion. Using this approach, streets are built to contain multiple oversized driving lanes and generous clear zones to meet high traffic volumes and allow space for potential crashes.
Evidence shows this design strategy has significant flaws, especially when implemented in urban areas where high speed is undesirable.
Emphasis on wide, simplified, and unobstructed streets causes drivers to lose their inhibitions. Generous and unobstructed driving lanes distorts judgments of speed, causing drivers to subconsciously go faster.
Driving speed increases as the lanes become wider. A 2001 study in the United States found widening lanes by 1 metre (3.2 feet) increased average speeds by 15 kph (9.3 mph). The same study illustrated that within a lane of 3.25 metres (10.6 feet), which is Cambodia’s urban street standard, driving speeds averaged an alarming 55 kph (34 mph).
As the saying goes, “speed kills.” These passive road design choices encourage higher driving speeds and ironically lead to more and deadlier accidents.
A proactive approach to road design would increase safety in the Kingdom’s urban areas.
This careful road design strategy involves street elements which guide and influence better driving behaviour by enforcing slow and cautious navigation. These measures are crucial in significantly reducing the severity of grave injury and decreasing the chance of an accident occurring in the first place. One supporting example is a 2019 study from Ghana that found “traffic calming devices reduce vehicular speeds and, thus, the incidence and severity of pedestrian injuries in built-up areas.”
Another comprehensive American study in 1997 examined risks associated with traffic speed. A vehicle travelling at 20 kph (12.4 mph) has an accident rate of only 5% and a fatality risk of 2%. Yet doubling the speed to 40 kph (24.8 mph) was shown to triple the rate of accidents to 15% and spike the fatality risk to 5%, the report stated.
As the Kingdom moves to expand and improve its road network, adapting a proactive approach would be more efficient than retroactively modifying streets.
Using various techniques referred to as ‘traffic calming measures,’ Cambodian towns and cities can reduce traffic speeds. Some interventions alter the physical configurations of roadways, while others change how drivers perceive and respond to streets.
The first alteration local designers can make is reducing lane numbers and their width from the usual 3.25 metres to 3 metres (9.8 feet) or less. Reductions help decrease crossing distance and reduce stoplight cycle time without impacting overall traffic flow.
The space gained from road space reduction can be better utilised as dedicated bus and protected bicycle lanes and on-street parking buffers to protect pedestrians. This is sorely needed in Cambodia, as illustrated by an accident in which a careening vehicle on Phnom Penh’s Monivong Boulevard killed a pedestrian on the sidewalk.
To further reduce motorist speed, streets should be designed with a chicane, or a lane shifting pattern, that slows drivers with shallow turns. This can be done by alternating parking or curb extensions into the desired pattern. Working on a similar principle, a pinch-point design extends sidewalks to narrow roadways, which restricts speeds and expands sidewalk space.
Planners can also utilise roadway centre islands. Combined with raised pedestrian crossings and located in the middle of city blocks, islands reduce speeding and provide safe crossings for pedestrians and cyclists.
Psychological cues also can complement physical restructuring. Trees, street furniture and narrowed building lines create visual indicators, making drivers more speed conscious, alert and aware of their surroundings.
Protected intersections
Intersections are by far the most dangerous road locations because traffic flow converges, visibility is limited and conflict points are plentiful. The danger is heightened by drivers often ignoring stop signs, leading to tragic consequences on a regular basis.
One of Cambodia’s most infamous hit-and-run incidents occurred at a Phnom Penh intersection in 2019. An underage driver barreled through a Toul Kork intersection with an SUV, killing motorcyclist Dum Rida.
A preferred method of improving intersections is to narrow corners using curb extensions. This sharpens the turn radius, which encourages slower turning speeds, decreases the distances pedestrians must cross and ensures good visibility for all users as they approach the intersection.
Another effective intersection safety measure is raising crosswalks to the same level as sidewalks, signalling to drivers that they are intruding on pedestrian space and should be alert. The slight ramp also serves as a speed bump to slow drivers.
Cambodian road engineers also should pay more attention to the largest group of road users: motorcyclists. Slip lanes for motorcycles, which account for four out of five vehicles, would allow riders to line up ahead of other vehicles when stopped at intersections and reduce conflict points.
Despite decades of top-down enforcement policy, traffic accidents continue to soar at alarming rates. Over the same 30-month period, traffic accidents led to 3,599 deaths compared to 3,056 attributed to Covid-19.
Given this grim reality, the Kingdom’s approach to road safety must be reconsidered. Instead of blaming drivers, authorities and city planners must recognise the dangerous environment which the incumbent road design approach has yielded.
As the current design paradigm kills and maims indiscriminately, the time has arrived to reassess our road priorities. We must stop pursuing speed and volume for motorists and instead place greater value on health and safety for everyone.
Ses Aronsakda is a junior researcher at Future Forum. Educated as an architect, he conducts research on Phnom Penh’s urban planning with interests in all aspects of cities and urban design.
https://southeastasiaglobe.com/cambodia ... et-design/
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
And incessant talking on phone (s) Have seen moto drivers on two phones...
- Freightdog
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4401
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2018 8:41 am
- Reputation: 3485
- Location: Attached to a suitcase between realities
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
There’s plenty that could be done with what they have now (no, I haven’t read the whole article)
You could design in all sorts of safety ideas, but unless the current driving and riding habits are educated out, it will be wasted, as people will find a way around them
-impatience
-selfishness
-lack of situation awareness
-no appreciation of consequences
The same road behaviours can be seen throughout Asia, Persia Middle East and lot of other places.
There’s little point in building stuff or adding things, if no one knows how to use it properly, or no intention of doing so. Poor or Rich alike. There’s little adherence to what already exists.
You could design in all sorts of safety ideas, but unless the current driving and riding habits are educated out, it will be wasted, as people will find a way around them
-impatience
-selfishness
-lack of situation awareness
-no appreciation of consequences
The same road behaviours can be seen throughout Asia, Persia Middle East and lot of other places.
There’s little point in building stuff or adding things, if no one knows how to use it properly, or no intention of doing so. Poor or Rich alike. There’s little adherence to what already exists.
Last edited by Freightdog on Tue Jul 12, 2022 9:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
Lots of fancy ideas there. And it's interesting to note that while mentioning Dum Rida's death in 2019 they felt it un-necessary to include the final outcome to that tragic incident.
ie. After 3 months behind bars and $70k compensation the perp walked free.
Applying a little Occam's Razor to the whole death on the roads thing I think simply applying the full force of the law equally to those who cause death on the roads will have a far greater impact than how the roads are designed.
Other, equally simple steps that could be taken that would be equally cost effective are :-
Mechanical road-worthiness tests for vehicles
driver education
ie. After 3 months behind bars and $70k compensation the perp walked free.
Applying a little Occam's Razor to the whole death on the roads thing I think simply applying the full force of the law equally to those who cause death on the roads will have a far greater impact than how the roads are designed.
Other, equally simple steps that could be taken that would be equally cost effective are :-
Mechanical road-worthiness tests for vehicles
driver education
Last edited by IraHayes on Tue Jul 12, 2022 9:19 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Freightdog
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4401
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2018 8:41 am
- Reputation: 3485
- Location: Attached to a suitcase between realities
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
Reducing lanes will have no effect when few follow the lanes that already exist.
Some, especially tuktuks follow the lines, not position between them. And then you get the fools who block the space in between, and make new lanes
Some, especially tuktuks follow the lines, not position between them. And then you get the fools who block the space in between, and make new lanes
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
How would we go in both directions in each lane if they reduce the width?
Sounds dangerous.
Sounds dangerous.
Money can't buy happiness but it can buy beer
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
It's all about making roads, education to cater for speeding, nothing about designing the cars and bikes so they can't speed.
I'm standing up, so I must be straight.
What's a poor man do when the blues keep following him around.(Smoking Dynamite)
What's a poor man do when the blues keep following him around.(Smoking Dynamite)
- John Bingham
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13786
- Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2014 11:26 pm
- Reputation: 8983
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
I couldn't agree more. People speed, drive drunk, run away from expensive (or not so expensive) vehicles that are presumably registered yet we hear nothing about how these are followed up. If you are wealthy and have some weight no law enforcement wants the problems that will result in pulling you up. Chinese gangsters drive around with impunity because they buy/ hire fancy cars and look important. People seem to crash regularly while obviously inebriated, yet are allowed to cool off and continue. It's better for the police to get a quick negotiation as they can take a nice cut for themselves, it's no use to them once it's gone to court and into the even more extortive justice system.
Silence, exile, and cunning.
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
Having an exchange with the author on Twitter, he's not having it that road design as the key ... to me it is 99% a bad training/license issue. Khmers learn for about 3 hours at a school, then pay for their test to be passed, it is utterly absurd. Take a look at st.51 on any night and count the number of morons going up it the wrong way, some like idiots that took a wrong turn, some at stupid speeds knowing exactly what they're doing. No amount of road design is going to fix that crap.
Meum est propositum in taberna mori,
ut sint Guinness proxima morientis ori.
tunc cantabunt letius angelorum chori:
"Sit Deus propitius huic potatori."
ut sint Guinness proxima morientis ori.
tunc cantabunt letius angelorum chori:
"Sit Deus propitius huic potatori."
- phuketrichard
- Expatriate
- Posts: 16884
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2014 5:17 pm
- Reputation: 5785
- Location: Atlantis
Re: Cambodia needs safer street designs
4 simple things that could be done
- Mandatory 2 hour "how to drive, laws" with video and teacher before license is issued
- Education
- Driver consideration of others on the road
- Enforcement of laws
In a nation run by swine, all pigs are upward-mobile and the rest of us are fucked until we can put our acts together: not necessarily to win, but mainly to keep from losing completely. HST
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 26 Replies
- 4843 Views
-
Last post by DavidK99
-
- 1 Replies
- 751 Views
-
Last post by schlarry
-
- 1 Replies
- 1801 Views
-
Last post by Clutch Cargo
-
- 61 Replies
- 12987 Views
-
Last post by scott61
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot], ali baba, Amazon [Bot], BongKingKong, Bongmab69, boringperson, Kammekor, Province, xandreu and 742 guests