Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
We can start conversing like adults whenever you're ready.StroppyChops wrote:We're having points now? When did that start?
In the meantime, talking to you gives the same level of satisfaction as talking to any other tuk-tuk driver.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4267
- Joined: Mon May 19, 2014 1:06 pm
- Reputation: 471
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
I agree, he deserves the punishment.
The law was in place before he decided not to follow it, and its not like it was only a foreigner that got caught, 2 locals went down with him and im sure they were treated way worse than the kiwi during this whole ordeal.
The law was in place before he decided not to follow it, and its not like it was only a foreigner that got caught, 2 locals went down with him and im sure they were treated way worse than the kiwi during this whole ordeal.
- StroppyChops
- The Missionary Man
- Posts: 10598
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 11:24 am
- Reputation: 1032
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
I give you special price - m'pay dolla. Where you go? Siem Reap? Gehenna?BOFH wrote:We can start conversing like adults whenever you're ready.StroppyChops wrote:We're having points now? When did that start?
In the meantime, talking to you gives the same level of satisfaction as talking to any other tuk-tuk driver.
Bodge: This ain't Kansas, and the neighbours ate Toto!
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
Interesting. This was ordered from the top level and sparked quite a debate. I agree that maximum penalty is a bit harsh for this crime. Guess they wanted to set an example. Kicking him out like the Cambodian government did to the Chinese factory owner that ripped apart a photo of Norodom Sihanouk last year(?) would have been enough imho.
General manager Philip Blackwood, 32, owner Tun Thurein, 40, and manager Htut Ko Ko Lwin, 26, were detained for police questioning Wednesday and the bar was shuttered after a complaint by an official from Myanmar’s Religious Department, police said.
“According to Mr Philip’s statement, they were trying to promote the bar. Buddha grabs people’s interest... however Buddhists cannot accept it,” a police official in Yangon’s Bahan township told reporters late Wednesday.
“This insults the religion. So we opened the case under the Religion Act. We will file a lawsuit,” he said, requesting not to be named.
Under the act, anyone who attempts to insult, destroy or damage any religion can be punished by a maximum of two years in jail, with another two-year penalty for those who attempt to insult religion through the written word.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/d ... -promotionAfter criticism erupted the bar - which opened just two weeks ago - deleted the post and wrote an apology on the Facebook page.
“VGastro management would like to express our sincere regret if we have offended the citizens of this wonderful city, who have welcomed us so warmly and generously,” it said.
“Our intention was never to cause offence to anyone or toward any religious group. Our ignorance is embarrassing.”
But the apology attracted a slew of angry comments from Burmese social media users including one saying “Shame on you!”, while another decried the bar management as “utterly unprofessional and culturally insensitive.”
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-12-26/n ... ar/5989322"I had no intention at all of insulting religion," Mr Blackwood told the court in comments read out in Burmese by a judge.
"I only did it for promotional purposes for my shop. I'm not guilty."
When the prosecutor asked whether he knew the law before entering the country, Mr Blackwood said he did not fully understand the legal system.
"I'm not guilty as I honestly posted it without knowing this problem could occur," he said, according to the judge.
“The charges should be dropped and all three men should be immediately and unconditionally released,” said Rupert Abbott, Amnesty International’s research director for Southeast Asia and the Pacific, speaking to DVB on Friday. “While international human rights law and standards permit certain restrictions to the right to freedom of expression, these restrictions are clearly defined and limited in scope. There is no way that the charges and prosecution in this case can meet the narrow human rights criteria for restricting the right to freedom expression, and therefore Myanmar is clearly violating this right.
“Pending their release, they must be granted full and unhindered access to their families and lawyers of their choosing and, where required, an interpreter,” he added.
The sentiment was backed by Phil Robertson, the deputy-director of Human Rights Watch’s Asia Division, who slammed the verdict and called into question the “lynch mob mentality” that provoked the charges.
“Demanding respect for religion doesn’t justify criminalising free speech or abusing other rights, and it certainly doesn’t vindicate the apparent lynch mob mentality that the Ma-Ba-Tha [hardline Buddhist group] have towards these three persons,” he told DVB. “The provisions of the penal code they are charged under are overly broad and essentially allow the authorities to criminalise speech about religion without effective restriction — when what is really needed here is a reasoned discussion about freedom of expression and religion.
“All three should be immediately released on bail and allowed to defend themselves against these charges – and the fact that they immediately apologised and withdrew the offending materials should be considered sympathetically and taken into account.”
Mark Farmaner, the director of Burma Campaign UK, said, “It is bizarre to be targeting men working in a small bar for insulting Buddhism, rather than targeting those responsible for shooting at monks and raiding monasteries to crush the uprising in 2007.”
https://www.dvb.no/news/amnesty-int-cal ... ngon/46689Although many hardline Buddhists have called for severe punishments to be meted out to the three defendants, other monks have now stood up to call for forgiveness in view of the circumstances, saying that the offending material was clearly not meant to be insulting and the fact that the bar managers issued a full apology.
Ashin Sopaka, a highly revered monk and writer based in Monywa, called for the trio to be released in the spirit of Buddhist tolerance and forgiveness.
“I was thinking what would The Buddha say in this issue, and he would say: ‘It’s no problem, I forgive you, but please do not make such a mistake again’,” he wrote.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
Where do you get that from? Not Cambodia anywayAlcohol is not compatible with buddhism.
Alcohol is available all over Burma and elsewhere; just do a search for for all the "Buddha bars" in SEA buddhist countries.
http://www.thaisabai.org/2014/05/happy- ... -ban-dung/
http://www.bali-indonesia.com/magazine/ ... ha-bar.htm
The Burmese religious outrage is political - nothing to do with what people drink.
Examples of new legislation proposed recently in Burma:
http://www.irrawaddy.org/burma/protecti ... ament.htmlA proposed Marriage Bill would require Buddhist women to seek permission from local authorities before marrying a man of another faith, while the Religious Conversion Bill creates new legal criteria for changing faiths. The conversion policy has received particular scorn from some of Burma’s minority faiths, including Christians and Muslims, who have historically been subject to religious persecution by the former military regime.
I agree that there was a certain stupidity/naivety shown by the Kiwi regarding local sentiment - but that doesn't merit 2 years in jail.
Also agree that FB is dangerous
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
The five precepts, the constitution of the basic Buddhist code of ethics.Anchor Moy wrote:Where do you get that from? Not Cambodia anywayAlcohol is not compatible with buddhism.
Surāmerayamajjapamādaṭṭhānā veramaṇī sikkhāpadaṃ samādiyāmi.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Prec ... ning_rules
- General Mackevili
- The General
- Posts: 18424
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 5:24 pm
- Reputation: 3418
- Location: The Kingdom
- Contact:
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
I think it's fucking ridiculous. Even based on that law, it's quite a stretch.
Even monks are trying to forgive the guy. It was an obvious accident and VERY debatable.
With such a harsh punishment for such a small deal, this no doubt hurts their "new" image.
Personally, they got in the news as soon as they charged the guys. I would have left it at that, or possibly give them that weakest sentence possible, just to save face.
Maybe they'll let him out in 6 months or less just to be in the news again.
Even monks are trying to forgive the guy. It was an obvious accident and VERY debatable.
With such a harsh punishment for such a small deal, this no doubt hurts their "new" image.
Personally, they got in the news as soon as they charged the guys. I would have left it at that, or possibly give them that weakest sentence possible, just to save face.
Maybe they'll let him out in 6 months or less just to be in the news again.
"Life is too important to take seriously."
"Life does not cease to be funny when people die any more than it ceases to be serious when people laugh."
Have a story or an anonymous news tip for CEO? Need advertising? CONTACT ME
Cambodia Expats Online is the most popular community in the country. JOIN TODAY
Follow CEO on social media:
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Google+
Instagram
"Life does not cease to be funny when people die any more than it ceases to be serious when people laugh."
Have a story or an anonymous news tip for CEO? Need advertising? CONTACT ME
Cambodia Expats Online is the most popular community in the country. JOIN TODAY
Follow CEO on social media:
YouTube
Google+
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
Yes right.BOFH wrote:The five precepts, the constitution of the basic Buddhist code of ethics.Anchor Moy wrote:Where do you get that from? Not Cambodia anywayAlcohol is not compatible with buddhism.
Surāmerayamajjapamādaṭṭhānā veramaṇī sikkhāpadaṃ samādiyāmi.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Prec ... ning_rules
1.Abstain from killing - see Cambodia, Sri Lanka and also Burma quite recently.
2.Don't take what doesn't belong to you - see the ruling classes in the above countries.
3.No sexual misconduct - I think Thailand and Cambodia will do as examples.
4.False speech - as above.
5. No fermented drinks such as rice wine etc. - which is why it is sold and made everywhere.
Buddhists don't always adhere to their code of ethics.
You can't really blame a foreigner for not doing so - particularly since it was through ignorance and not to insult or harm.
Welease Woger.
- phuketrichard
- Expatriate
- Posts: 16879
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2014 5:17 pm
- Reputation: 5782
- Location: Atlantis
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
an ole saying
an old man was arrested for pissing on an old Buddha statue,
when he was asked why he choose there to piss he relied.
"show me where Buddha is not an there i will piss"
For me, same as the guys going to be shot in Indonesia
he did the crime that was on the books
now he must pay, ignorance of the law ( regardless of how we might think) is no excuse
I am sure he meant no harm but......
Plus keep this in mind,
You can say coming from me thats crazy BUT all i am saying is be aware of what your doing wherever ur doing it.
an old man was arrested for pissing on an old Buddha statue,
when he was asked why he choose there to piss he relied.
"show me where Buddha is not an there i will piss"
For me, same as the guys going to be shot in Indonesia
he did the crime that was on the books
now he must pay, ignorance of the law ( regardless of how we might think) is no excuse
I am sure he meant no harm but......
Plus keep this in mind,
from K440The report mentions that the sentence was for the original offense and also ignoring the orders of an official. If the orders of the official were a warning to take them down and that was ignored
You can say coming from me thats crazy BUT all i am saying is be aware of what your doing wherever ur doing it.
In a nation run by swine, all pigs are upward-mobile and the rest of us are fucked until we can put our acts together: not necessarily to win, but mainly to keep from losing completely. HST
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Re: Kiwi faces 4 years jail for Buddha ad images in Burma
I've read about half a dozen articles on this which all say that he was very sorry, apologized immediately and took it off FB.I have not been able to find any suggestion that there was a prior warning which was ignored; I just checked the other forum which links to this article:phuketrichard wrote:a
...
Plus keep this in mind,from K440The report mentions that the sentence was for the original offense and also ignoring the orders of an official. If the orders of the official were a warning to take them down and that was ignored
You can say coming from me thats crazy BUT all i am saying is be aware of what your doing wherever ur doing it.
http://www.utsandiego.com/news/2015/mar ... insulting/The three were arrested in December after the image was used to promote the tapas bar and lounge, and have been detained in Myanmar's notorious Insein prison. The online ad was removed and an apology was posted.
Ok, this article is a bit clearer. The prior warning refers to bar closing time, nothing to do with the main offense.
http://www.utsandiego.com/news/2015/mar ... insulting/The first charge pertains to destruction, damage or defilement of sacred places or objects with intent or knowledge that the action could cause insult, while the latter pertains to disobeying an order issued by a public servant. The trio’s attorney said the charge related to keeping the V Gastro Bar open after authorized hours.
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 12 Replies
- 2779 Views
-
Last post by Tootsfriend
-
- 39 Replies
- 7105 Views
-
Last post by ofparadise
-
- 10 Replies
- 1725 Views
-
Last post by Pseudonomdeplume
-
- 2 Replies
- 1223 Views
-
Last post by CEOCambodiaNews
-
- 351 Replies
- 106231 Views
-
Last post by phuketrichard
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot], barang_TK, Bluenose, Deefer, Freightdog, jaynewcastle, John Bingham, kgbagent, KunKhmerSR, Moe, Richy9999Rich, Semrush [Bot], Soriya, steevee, ThiagoA, xandreu and 881 guests