On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
According to the article, brain chemistry theory was based on rigged trials.
The selfy approach to science.
We all know that when you take selfies, you take 30 pictures, throw away the 29 where you look bleary-eyed or double-chinned, and pick out the best one to be your Tinder profile picture. It turned out that the drug companies – who fund almost all the research into these drugs – were taking this approach to studying chemical antidepressants. They would fund huge numbers of studies, throw away all the ones that suggested the drugs had very limited effects, and then only release the ones that showed success. To give one example: in one trial, the drug was given to 245 patients, but the drug company published the results for only 27 of them. Those 27 patients happened to be the ones the drug seemed to work for. Suddenly, Professor Kirsch realised that the 70% figure couldn’t be right.
It turns out that between 65 and 80% of people on antidepressants are depressed again within a year. I had thought that I was freakish for remaining depressed while on these drugs. In fact, Kirsch explained to me in Massachusetts, I was totally typical. These drugs are having a positive effect for some people – but they clearly can’t be the main solution for the majority of us, because we’re still depressed even when we take them. At the moment, we offer depressed people a menu with only one option on it. I certainly don’t want to take anything off the menu – but I realised, as I spent time with him, that we would have to expand the menu.
This led Professor Kirsch to ask a more basic question, one he was surprised to be asking. How do we know depression is even caused by low serotonin at all? When he began to dig, it turned out that the evidence was strikingly shaky. Professor Andrew Scull of Princeton, writing in the Lancet, explained that attributing depression to spontaneously low serotonin is “deeply misleading and unscientific”. Dr David Healy told me: “There was never any basis for it, ever. It was just marketing copy.”
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 3858
- Joined: Mon May 19, 2014 7:49 am
- Reputation: 978
- Location: Outside of Kampong Cham city
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
Probably Charlie, I couldn't afford Dr. Lambo's bar tab.
As my old Cajun bait seller used to say, "I opes you luck.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Sun Oct 22, 2017 12:17 pm
- Reputation: 36
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
Sunrise Mental Health Clinic. I believe the British Embassy has a place they refer to also.
Alternatively, there are anonymous chat groups in your respective countries if you seek help online or even by phone.
AA has a support group, but they don't treat depression directly, they just recognize it and occasionally some members have direct experience overcoming that as well.
Best to get some good advice.
I think Khmer support is limited but growing.
Melvin Udall: Never, never, interrupt me, okay?
Not if there's a fire, not even if you hear the sound of a thud from my home and one week later there's a smell coming from there that can only be a decaying human body and you have to hold a hanky to your face because the stench is so thick that you think you're going to faint.
Even then, don't come knocking...Not for ANY reason.
Not if there's a fire, not even if you hear the sound of a thud from my home and one week later there's a smell coming from there that can only be a decaying human body and you have to hold a hanky to your face because the stench is so thick that you think you're going to faint.
Even then, don't come knocking...Not for ANY reason.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
A handicapped rice farmer is extremely low on the social scale. By giving him a cow, they improved his social status - and therefore, improved prospects for his whole family. He will earn more money, but there's more to it than that. As a cow-owner, he has more respect from the village.(Owning one cow does not make you a dairy farmer, but its sure as hell a step up from being a rice farmer who has to rent a buffalo from his neighbours.) Status being what it is here, that could be a powerful anti-depressant.He asked them to explain, and they told him about a rice farmer they knew whose left leg was blown off by a landmine. He was fitted with a new limb, but he felt constantly anxious about the future, and was filled with despair. The doctors sat with him, and talked through his troubles. They realised that even with his new artificial limb, his old job—working in the rice paddies—was leaving him constantly stressed and in physical pain, and that was making him want to just stop living. So they had an idea. They believed that if he became a dairy farmer, he could live differently. So they bought him a cow. In the months and years that followed, his life changed. His depression—which had been profound—went away. “You see, doctor,” they told him, the cow was an “antidepressant”.
There's even a little NGO who does this - donates cows to poor Cambodians - Cows for Cambodia. It's an Aussie thing.
http://www.cowsforcambodia.com/info/joi ... -cambodia/
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
Alternatively you can wind up causing social unrest in the village. I do some charity work in 1 village but it is causing a ruckus because the people who are not dirt poor think its unfair that poor people are getting al the help. So if you give1 cow, you better have a whole herd to hand out to maintain social harmony in the villageAnchor Moy wrote: ↑Wed Jan 10, 2018 9:19 amA handicapped rice farmer is extremely low on the social scale. By giving him a cow, they improved his social status - and therefore, improved prospects for his whole family. He will earn more money, but there's more to it than that. As a cow-owner, he has more respect from the village.(Owning one cow does not make you a dairy farmer, but its sure as hell a step up from being a rice farmer who has to rent a buffalo from his neighbours.) Status being what it is here, that could be a powerful anti-depressant.He asked them to explain, and they told him about a rice farmer they knew whose left leg was blown off by a landmine. He was fitted with a new limb, but he felt constantly anxious about the future, and was filled with despair. The doctors sat with him, and talked through his troubles. They realised that even with his new artificial limb, his old job—working in the rice paddies—was leaving him constantly stressed and in physical pain, and that was making him want to just stop living. So they had an idea. They believed that if he became a dairy farmer, he could live differently. So they bought him a cow. In the months and years that followed, his life changed. His depression—which had been profound—went away. “You see, doctor,” they told him, the cow was an “antidepressant”.
There's even a little NGO who does this - donates cows to poor Cambodians - Cows for Cambodia. It's an Aussie thing.
http://www.cowsforcambodia.com/info/joi ... -cambodia/
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
Yeah totally agree. However, as an individual remedy for improving someone's mental state, I imagine the gift of a cow would be quite efficient, and the person concerned would rather be hated than pitied.pczz wrote: ↑Wed Jan 10, 2018 9:43 am
Alternatively you can wind up causing social unrest in the village. I do some charity work in 1 village but it is causing a ruckus because the people who are not dirt poor think its unfair that poor people are getting al the help. So if you give1 cow, you better have a whole herd to hand out to maintain social harmony in the village
But, as you say, this also raises questions about treating the individual in a communal society, or upsetting village eco-systems.
I don't know anything about the cow NGO and how it works, or how they choose who gets a cow and who doesn't. But I can see it could get tricky.
It would probably be better if the cows were sold rather than given - pay later or something.
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
Interestingly, maybe stealing your neighbour's land causes a smaller social unrest than giving a very poor family a cow.Anchor Moy wrote: ↑Wed Jan 10, 2018 10:26 amYeah totally agree. However, as an individual remedy for improving someone's mental state, I imagine the gift of a cow would be quite efficient, and the person concerned would rather be hated than pitied.pczz wrote: ↑Wed Jan 10, 2018 9:43 am
Alternatively you can wind up causing social unrest in the village. I do some charity work in 1 village but it is causing a ruckus because the people who are not dirt poor think its unfair that poor people are getting al the help. So if you give1 cow, you better have a whole herd to hand out to maintain social harmony in the village
But, as you say, this also raises questions about treating the individual in a communal society, or upsetting village eco-systems.
I don't know anything about the cow NGO and how it works, or how they choose who gets a cow and who doesn't. But I can see it could get tricky.
It would probably be better if the cows were sold rather than given - pay later or something.
One family affected, as opposed to a whole community outraged?
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
TPO Cambodia, Sunrise Mental Clinic, Indigo Internationaltaabarang wrote:"If any are feeling bad, really bad, just get help. Call or contact a professional organization you trust..."
Whom would you suggest in Cambodia, especially one who is fluent in both Khmer and English?
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
Will any of those places give me me a cow?epidemiks wrote: ↑Wed Jan 10, 2018 12:28 pmTPO Cambodia, Sunrise Mental Clinic, Indigo Internationaltaabarang wrote:"If any are feeling bad, really bad, just get help. Call or contact a professional organization you trust..."
Whom would you suggest in Cambodia, especially one who is fluent in both Khmer and English?
- that genius
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4064
- Joined: Wed Dec 06, 2017 7:53 am
- Reputation: 960
Re: On cows and depression: Cambodian doctors getting it right for once.
No, but they may milk you.
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 0 Replies
- 1307 Views
-
Last post by CEOCambodiaNews
-
- 0 Replies
- 1336 Views
-
Last post by CEOCambodiaNews
-
- 4 Replies
- 936 Views
-
Last post by BklynBoy
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: armchairlawyer, Bing [Bot], drozd, Lost50, Patcan and 1001 guests