What books are you reading?
Re: What books are you reading?
I'm sorry but The Mismeasure of Man is an outdated, widely criticised work of historical straw manning & misrepresentation. Most of the studies he references are from the 1950's and even then he does not honesty represent the methods & conclusions drawn by the original authors. His refutation of The Bell Curve is a case in point, dishonestly misrepresenting Murray & Herrnstein's conclusions for his own notoriety.
A lot has happened since the 90's, let alone the 50's.
Robert Plomin's, 'Blueprint: How DNA makes us who we are', summarises recent developments well (that's not to say that GWAS & polygenic scores are without controversy).
The problem with this area is that no one knows what to do with evidence that genetics plays a strong part in determining individual outcomes (to say nothing of groups), it doesn't fit societies model of egalitarianism, where every child is able to become a rocket scientist or Nobel laureate. It's important though that despite the awkwardness of these discussions and uncomfortable conclusions, scientific progress is not sacrificed on the alter of social justice and identity politics. We have to find a way to accept the facts (whatever they may be) and still treat everyone with the dignity & respect they deserve.
Re: What books are you reading?
https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/ ... 1982147990
Not finished yet but a fascinating look at the historical interpretation of The Book of Revelation and how it has affected global events, as well as the contents of the actual scripture, how it was fairly controversially included in the Bible and it's objectively non-nonsensical narrative. Poorly written knock off of The Book of Daniel might be one conclusion to draw. Just don't tell the evangelists.
The author is also interesting, Bart Ehrman was born into in a moderately Christian household, was 'born again' as a teenager and became an ardent evangelist, attending the Moody Bible Institute. He later moderated his views to a belief in liberal Christianity, before eventually deciding it was all bullshit and becoming an atheist in mid-life. Quite a journey.
Re: What books are you reading?
No, you are completely wrong. Gould had a very good understanding of reality. You don't understand "genetics" ...you are merely susceptible to believe in the fantasy myth of IQ promulgated by Western prejudice to rationalize a particular interpretation of social reality that fails to take into account the plain and obvious differences between deeply embedded socio-cultural and linguistic forces that limit the application of IQ testing.down_time wrote: ↑Wed Sep 13, 2023 2:59 pmI'm sorry but The Mismeasure of Man is an outdated, widely criticised work of historical straw manning & misrepresentation. Most of the studies he references are from the 1950's and even then he does not honesty represent the methods & conclusions drawn by the original authors. His refutation of The Bell Curve is a case in point, dishonestly misrepresenting Murray & Herrnstein's conclusions for his own notoriety.
A lot has happened since the 90's, let alone the 50's.
Robert Plomin's, 'Blueprint: How DNA makes us who we are', summarises recent developments well (that's not to say that GWAS & polygenic scores are without controversy).
The problem with this area is that no one knows what to do with evidence that genetics plays a strong part in determining individual outcomes (to say nothing of groups), it doesn't fit societies model of egalitarianism, where every child is able to become a rocket scientist or Nobel laureate. It's important though that despite the awkwardness of these discussions and uncomfortable conclusions, scientific progress is not sacrificed on the alter of social justice and identity politics. We have to find a way to accept the facts (whatever they may be) and still treat everyone with the dignity & respect they deserve.
IQ testing is subjective to a degree that renders comparisons between people useless. If you actually took the time to read this book, you would see that he explores the very long history of prejudiced and racialized interpretation of intelligence long before IQ tests were invented when "scientists" compared the size and shape of different human skulls as evidence of varied intelligence.
Since Gould wrote this excellent book, there has been almost nobody trying to advance any argument, much less "research" to validate the authenticity of IQ testing.
Simply put, there are different kinds of intelligence. IQ testing does not work as an effective measure to compare them. On the contrary, IQ testing favours people with STEM talent (like engineers and mathematicians) and cannot measure people who have abstract, artistic and synthetic abilities, (like painters and poets).
~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~
“There are terrible difficulties in the notion of probability, but we may ignore them at present.” - Bertrand Russell
“There are terrible difficulties in the notion of probability, but we may ignore them at present.” - Bertrand Russell
Re: What books are you reading?
Anyway, I am now reading this book. Very interesting... about how you aren't really making the choices you thought you were. (How studios "over-study" audience tastes, which leads to the fakey planned design of movie plots, etc, and makes it nearly impossible that any great movies can ever get made ever again.) But you guys don't know about that. You can go on listening to the awful Eagles and repulsive Freddy Mercury down at the tedious bar...
Anyway, I never subscribed to Netflix. I just use PB...
Anyway, I never subscribed to Netflix. I just use PB...
~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~
“There are terrible difficulties in the notion of probability, but we may ignore them at present.” - Bertrand Russell
“There are terrible difficulties in the notion of probability, but we may ignore them at present.” - Bertrand Russell
- hdgh29
- Expatriate
- Posts: 326
- Joined: Tue Mar 19, 2019 12:50 pm
- Reputation: 207
- Location: siem reap
- Contact:
Re: What books are you reading?
Oh joy - 2 books this week from two of my favourite authors, Robert Goddard and Mick Herron. Downloaded both and reading them now. Also downloaded The Chase by Ava Glass, who the Guardian compared to Le Carre. Total crap, reads like it was written by an AI text generator. Le Carre indeeed - Enid Blyton could do better.
"I tried being reasonable. Didn't like it" (Clint Eastwood)
- Big Daikon
- Expatriate
- Posts: 3189
- Joined: Mon Dec 09, 2019 8:07 am
- Reputation: 2605
Re: What books are you reading?
This is not correct. Gould was a fraud who was more of an ideologue than a scientist. He and his pal Lewontin called themselves Marxist biologists.orichá wrote: ↑Thu Sep 14, 2023 9:42 am No, you are completely wrong. Gould had a very good understanding of reality. You don't understand "genetics" ...you are merely susceptible to believe in the fantasy myth of IQ promulgated by Western prejudice to rationalize a particular interpretation of social reality that fails to take into account the plain and obvious differences between deeply embedded socio-cultural and linguistic forces that limit the application of IQ testing.
IQ testing is subjective to a degree that renders comparisons between people useless. If you actually took the time to read this book, you would see that he explores the very long history of prejudiced and racialized interpretation of intelligence long before IQ tests were invented when "scientists" compared the size and shape of different human skulls as evidence of varied intelligence.
Since Gould wrote this excellent book, there has been almost nobody trying to advance any argument, much less "research" to validate the authenticity of IQ testing.
Simply put, there are different kinds of intelligence. IQ testing does not work as an effective measure to compare them. On the contrary, IQ testing favours people with STEM talent (like engineers and mathematicians) and cannot measure people who have abstract, artistic and synthetic abilities, (like painters and poets).
Gould did a decent job of documenting early attempts at measuring intelligence. He focuses more on alleged racial/cultural biases in early IQ testing. Creators of IQ tests have spent decades reducing the cultural loading in IQ tests with more of less the same results and inequalities of mean scores.
No less than the APA weighed in on the validity of modern IQ tests and concluded they were a reasonably accurate measurement of cognitive capacity.
Try a Google search of "Gould & fraud".
Back to books. Read this recently. Eye-opening and frightening.
Re: What books are you reading?
Wow, this is the weirdest book I've encountered in a long time. It somehow reminds me of how much I miss soaping up a female in the shower... it's so long ago, I can't recall how it feels...
~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~+~
“There are terrible difficulties in the notion of probability, but we may ignore them at present.” - Bertrand Russell
“There are terrible difficulties in the notion of probability, but we may ignore them at present.” - Bertrand Russell
- Fridaywithmateo
- Expatriate
- Posts: 1174
- Joined: Thu Sep 28, 2023 7:11 am
- Reputation: 163
- Location: Cambodia
- Contact:
Re: What books are you reading?
Huang Di Nei Jing ... written by China's first Emperor ... prolly the best medical journal even ... big book, long book ... but damn good ... ancient wisdom of one of China's great men ... translated in nearly every language ...
First post as a newbee in CEO.
First post as a newbee in CEO.
- HaifongWangchuck
- Expatriate
- Posts: 274
- Joined: Sat Jul 01, 2023 8:26 am
- Reputation: 58
- Location: Sovannaphum
Re: What books are you reading?
Currently reading "The Spoilers" by Rex Beach, a 1906 novel about gold mining and greed in the prospecting town of Nome in the Alaska colony during the late 1800s/early 1900s.
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 3 Replies
- 1554 Views
-
Last post by ali baba
-
- 10 Replies
- 4529 Views
-
Last post by techietraveller84
-
- 3 Replies
- 1792 Views
-
Last post by Kuroneko
-
- 37 Replies
- 9211 Views
-
Last post by Lost50
-
- 4 Replies
- 594 Views
-
Last post by johnny lightning
-
- 6 Replies
- 3635 Views
-
Last post by John Bingham
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Alex, Bing [Bot], BongKingKong, Cooldude, Google [Bot], John Bingham, Kammekor, Majestic-12 [Bot], MSNbot Media, Richy9999Rich, Spigzy, xandreu, Zyzz and 954 guests