Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
Should elephant-riding in Thailand (and elsewhere) be banned ? Or what should be done ?
On Wednesday a Thai elephant in Chang Mai province killed his mahout while taking a tourist family on a ride. Very sad.
In June, also in Thailand, a man was killed by an elephant while eating in a restaurant: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/j ... restaurant
This should be raising some serious questions about elephant-riding and treatment of elephants. I admit that I have ridden on elephants before, but don't think I would do it now.
On Wednesday a Thai elephant in Chang Mai province killed his mahout while taking a tourist family on a ride. Very sad.
In June, also in Thailand, a man was killed by an elephant while eating in a restaurant: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/j ... restaurant
This should be raising some serious questions about elephant-riding and treatment of elephants. I admit that I have ridden on elephants before, but don't think I would do it now.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/a ... e-touristsAgence France-Presse in Bangkok.
An elephant in northern Thailand killed its handler before running off into the jungle with three terrified Chinese tourists still on its back, police said.
..Police said that on Wednesday morning a Chinese family of three – a father, mother and a young child – were taking a ride on the male elephant when it turned suddenly on its new keeper, goring him to death...
Rides are a popular and lucrative tourist activity but many animal rights groups say it is cruel and stressful for the animals...
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 1263
- Joined: Sun Mar 29, 2015 6:12 pm
- Reputation: 12
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
I think I'd prioritize the end of slavery in Thailand over elephant rights... but that's just me.
"If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever." - George Orwell
- phuketrichard
- Expatriate
- Posts: 16875
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2014 5:17 pm
- Reputation: 5781
- Location: Atlantis
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
come up with a suggestion on how a Mahout is supposed to feed his elephant
I visited a few sanctuaries in Thailand over the years and feel its a great idea, especially the ones where they are allowed to roam, but it costs $$$
The treatment of them is another matter, an there's some terrible video's floating around how they were trained, but i think nowadays's its not as it was before. ( or so i hope)
You have a higher chance of dying on the roads in Thailand, than on an elephant
I visited a few sanctuaries in Thailand over the years and feel its a great idea, especially the ones where they are allowed to roam, but it costs $$$
The treatment of them is another matter, an there's some terrible video's floating around how they were trained, but i think nowadays's its not as it was before. ( or so i hope)
You have a higher chance of dying on the roads in Thailand, than on an elephant
In a nation run by swine, all pigs are upward-mobile and the rest of us are fucked until we can put our acts together: not necessarily to win, but mainly to keep from losing completely. HST
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
We could also think about more than one thing at a time if we put our minds to it.TheGrinchSR wrote:I think I'd prioritize the end of slavery in Thailand over elephant rights... but that's just me.
It's a question I'm asking. If they stop elephant-rides then what to do with the elephants ? Two people killed in 2/3 months is not a lot, but I'm sure it got more (bad) press than the many road accidents. It's also a sign that these elephants are not happy.phuketrichard wrote:come up with a suggestion on how a Mahout is supposed to feed his elephant
I visited a few sanctuaries in Thailand over the years and feel its a great idea, especially the ones where they are allowed to roam, but it costs $$$
The treatment of them is another matter, an there's some terrible video's floating around how they were trained, but i think nowadays's its not as it was before. ( or so i hope)
You have a higher chance of dying on the roads in Thailand, than on an elephant
Elephant sanctuaries are a great idea, but as you say cost big bucks, and can they generate enough revenue to support the 4000 (according to the article) elephants in captivity ? And what about the 4000 mahouts ?
I don't have the answers, but I think that people should be asking questions because the present situation is apparently not good enough.
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
No, unless they restart using elephants for timber extraction,they would have no value otherwise.How much are you willing to pay to feed them each year?
General Mackevili: I just don't want you littering our forum with your drivel.
- frank lee bent
- Expatriate
- Posts: 11330
- Joined: Sat May 17, 2014 4:10 am
- Reputation: 2094
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
nailed it mr hammer
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 1263
- Joined: Sun Mar 29, 2015 6:12 pm
- Reputation: 12
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
You live in Asia and think that trying to get a government to concentrate on two issues at the same time is possible? I envy your optimism and would humbly suggest that it's the optimism which means that important issues never get tackled because they get lost in the noise of a million crappy issues. Thousands of people enslaved vs. a few unhappy elephants? Priorities need to be established and the elephants, for the moment, need to lose in that battle.Anchor Moy wrote:We could also think about more than one thing at a time if we put our minds to it.TheGrinchSR wrote:I think I'd prioritize the end of slavery in Thailand over elephant rights... but that's just me.
It's a question I'm asking. If they stop elephant-rides then what to do with the elephants ? Two people killed in 2/3 months is not a lot, but I'm sure it got more (bad) press than the many road accidents. It's also a sign that these elephants are not happy.phuketrichard wrote:come up with a suggestion on how a Mahout is supposed to feed his elephant
I visited a few sanctuaries in Thailand over the years and feel its a great idea, especially the ones where they are allowed to roam, but it costs $$$
The treatment of them is another matter, an there's some terrible video's floating around how they were trained, but i think nowadays's its not as it was before. ( or so i hope)
You have a higher chance of dying on the roads in Thailand, than on an elephant
Elephant sanctuaries are a great idea, but as you say cost big bucks, and can they generate enough revenue to support the 4000 (according to the article) elephants in captivity ? And what about the 4000 mahouts ?
I don't have the answers, but I think that people should be asking questions because the present situation is apparently not good enough.
"If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever." - George Orwell
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
I think you misunderstood me. Perhaps I should have said that I myself find it possible to support anti-slavery measures, while also wondering if Thailand has an elephant problem because they are killing people.TheGrinchSR wrote:You live in Asia and think that trying to get a government to concentrate on two issues at the same time is possible? I envy your optimism and would humbly suggest that it's the optimism which means that important issues never get tackled because they get lost in the noise of a million crappy issues. Thousands of people enslaved vs. a few unhappy elephants? Priorities need to be established and the elephants, for the moment, need to lose in that battle.Anchor Moy wrote:We could also think about more than one thing at a time if we put our minds to it. .TheGrinchSR wrote:I think I'd prioritize the end of slavery in Thailand over elephant rights... but that's just me.
Or maybe I misunderstood you when you said"I", and you actually meant "I, if I was the Thai govt, would..." In that case, no, IMHO I don't think they can deal with elephants when there are so many bloggers to lock up and journalists to sue etc. Never mind the slaves or the elephants.
I do post about Human Rights, but I'm also fond of elephants. Fair enough ?
And I'm not optimistic at all.
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
I don't think a couple of isolated unconnected deaths is a reason to ban something. If I did I'd have to argue in favour of banning anything electrical or mechanical due to the risk of electrocution or trauma.
I'd probably be in favour of stricter regulation around elephant attractions or having them phased out if I knew more about them. But treatment of elephants wasn't the focus of the OP.
Kill it, cook it, eat it!
I'd probably be in favour of stricter regulation around elephant attractions or having them phased out if I knew more about them. But treatment of elephants wasn't the focus of the OP.
Slavery is already illegal and most victims of human trafficking have been defrauded of their wages, not kidnapped. Labour laws are notoriously difficult to enforce in remote locations and private residences, which is why slavery still occurs in all countries today. Have you written to your repressentative demanding that they focus the full force of the state into investigating and prosecuting slavery?TheGrinchSR wrote:I think I'd prioritize the end of slavery in Thailand over elephant rights... but that's just me.
The continued existence of agricultural slavery might be hard to believe, but exist it does, and at a widespread levels across the globe.
What might be even more surprising, especially to American consumers, is the prevalence of slavery on farms across the United States. CIW – an anti-slavery and workers’ rights group based in Florida – estimates that, on a regular day, as many as 5% of American farm workers are forced laborers, working against their wills.
http://themarginalized.com/2010/09/08/h ... ed-states/
Modern day victims of slavery are often young women from eastern Europe, thinking they are coming to England to work as cleaners or au pairs, only to be forced into prostitution.
The Home Office estimated in 2003 that 4,000 women were trafficked into the UK for sexual exploitation. It is thought the figure may have grown since.
I was kept locked in the house for two weeks - he raped and slapped me every day
-A sex slave victim's story
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/6459369.stm
Why would we continue feeding these elephants? Animals don't receive pensions or enjoy comfortable retirements.phuketrichard wrote:come up with a suggestion on how a Mahout is supposed to feed his elephant
I visited a few sanctuaries in Thailand over the years and feel its a great idea, especially the ones where they are allowed to roam, but it costs $$$
Kill it, cook it, eat it!
Scarier than malaria.
Re: Elephant-riding in Thailand - should it be banned ?
Agreed they seem very isolated incidents, and nowhere near fatalaties from dogs for example. 4.5 – 4.7 million Americans are bitten by dogs every year, and last year 32 people died as a result of the bites, with a similar number the year before.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fatal_dog ... ted_States I would be more in favour of appropriate regulation. I won't start on the firearm or motor vehicle related deathsali baba wrote:I don't think a couple of isolated unconnected deaths is a reason to ban something. If I did I'd have to argue in favour of banning anything electrical or mechanical due to the risk of electrocution or trauma.
I'd probably be in favour of stricter regulation around elephant attractions or having them phased out if I knew more about them.
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 4 Replies
- 1756 Views
-
Last post by AndyKK
-
- 2 Replies
- 1673 Views
-
Last post by CEOCambodiaNews
-
- 3 Replies
- 1877 Views
-
Last post by AndyKK
-
- 111 Replies
- 18036 Views
-
Last post by HappyChappy
-
- 4 Replies
- 1711 Views
-
Last post by SternAAlbifrons
-
- 0 Replies
- 665 Views
-
Last post by roadman
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 273 guests