No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1975.
- Earl of Mercia
- Expatriate
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2023 10:21 pm
- Reputation: 49
No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1975.
Memories of the final days of the Vietnam War are often triggered by infamous photographs of the hectic evacuation of the U.S. embassy in Saigon, a day before South Vietnam’s surrender in late April 1975. The image of a North Vietnamese tank crashing through the wrought-iron gate of Independence Palace is symbolic of the end to U.S. military presence in the region.
Yet it was on a small, rock-fringed Cambodian island that the Americans fought their final mishandled battle of the generation-defining war.
Some 50 kilometres off the coast of Sihanoukville sits tiny Koh Tang, its coral-sand beaches bloodstained from the offensive presence of the Khmer Rouge militias that once patrolled it.
The isle’s rarely used English name, Legend Island, suits the stories that followed the Mayaguez incident, the only ground combat between U.S. forces and the Khmer Rouge. It took place on Koh Tang from 12 to 15 May 1975, a mere two weeks after the fall of Saigon, following the capture of an American merchant vessel in disputed waters.
Nearly five decades later, the 18 U.S. servicemen presumed to have died on Koh Tang – three of whose remains have never been recovered – have become an unfinished priority for a U.S. agency dedicated to that task. Three of the 18 were left behind following the battle. Finding them, and another 30 American soldiers lost in Cambodia during the spillover from the war in Vietnam, has fallen to the Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency (DPAA).
Full article :
https://focus-cambodia.com/article/maya ... etnam-war/
P.S. I didn’t know the American Ambassador to Cambodia was called Patrick Murphy,does Paddy double up as the Ireland Ambassador also?
Yet it was on a small, rock-fringed Cambodian island that the Americans fought their final mishandled battle of the generation-defining war.
Some 50 kilometres off the coast of Sihanoukville sits tiny Koh Tang, its coral-sand beaches bloodstained from the offensive presence of the Khmer Rouge militias that once patrolled it.
The isle’s rarely used English name, Legend Island, suits the stories that followed the Mayaguez incident, the only ground combat between U.S. forces and the Khmer Rouge. It took place on Koh Tang from 12 to 15 May 1975, a mere two weeks after the fall of Saigon, following the capture of an American merchant vessel in disputed waters.
Nearly five decades later, the 18 U.S. servicemen presumed to have died on Koh Tang – three of whose remains have never been recovered – have become an unfinished priority for a U.S. agency dedicated to that task. Three of the 18 were left behind following the battle. Finding them, and another 30 American soldiers lost in Cambodia during the spillover from the war in Vietnam, has fallen to the Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency (DPAA).
Full article :
https://focus-cambodia.com/article/maya ... etnam-war/
P.S. I didn’t know the American Ambassador to Cambodia was called Patrick Murphy,does Paddy double up as the Ireland Ambassador also?
- Earl of Mercia
- Expatriate
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2023 10:21 pm
- Reputation: 49
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
Part of it reads like a clip from the Oliver Stone movie Platoon,where Willem Defoe’s Sergeant Elias is trying to make it back to the Huey helicopter after being shot multiple times by the evil Sergeant Barnes played brilliantly by Tom Berenger :
“Only some of the key personnel carried radios and had call signs during the battle,” Williamson said. “But these guys were a machine gun team: no radios, no call signs and no real training (if any) in their use. So finding a radio on the island doesn’t connect to any of the missing personnel, except that someone might have come across equipment that was left or lost in the battle,” he said.
Yet former Air Force Staff Sergeant Robert Velie claimed that as the last helicopter was leaving Koh Tang island, he received a radio transmission from one of the missing Marines, asking when the next chopper was coming back for them. Velie and his team were coordinating the battle from aboard the EC-130E Airborne Battlefield Command and Control Center. Initially thinking it might be a trick, Velie requested an authentication code, and the Marine provided the correct response.
“Only some of the key personnel carried radios and had call signs during the battle,” Williamson said. “But these guys were a machine gun team: no radios, no call signs and no real training (if any) in their use. So finding a radio on the island doesn’t connect to any of the missing personnel, except that someone might have come across equipment that was left or lost in the battle,” he said.
Yet former Air Force Staff Sergeant Robert Velie claimed that as the last helicopter was leaving Koh Tang island, he received a radio transmission from one of the missing Marines, asking when the next chopper was coming back for them. Velie and his team were coordinating the battle from aboard the EC-130E Airborne Battlefield Command and Control Center. Initially thinking it might be a trick, Velie requested an authentication code, and the Marine provided the correct response.
- Kung-fu Hillbilly
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4170
- Joined: Sat May 17, 2014 11:26 am
- Reputation: 4984
- Location: Behind you.
- Earl of Mercia
- Expatriate
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2023 10:21 pm
- Reputation: 49
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
Congratulations on posting a completely different article on the same subject five years ago,is nobody allowed to broach the subject ever again or something?Kung-fu Hillbilly wrote: ↑Sat Dec 23, 2023 10:22 pm cambodian-culture-and-language/leave-ma ... 20853.html
- Kung-fu Hillbilly
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4170
- Joined: Sat May 17, 2014 11:26 am
- Reputation: 4984
- Location: Behind you.
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
It's not that at all. The link pertains to the subject with further reading being presented by members here who know a great deal about the incident, and other information about the event for anyone who would like to search more on the topic.Earl of Mercia wrote: ↑Sun Dec 24, 2023 12:16 amCongratulations on posting a completely different article on the same subject five years ago,is nobody allowed to broach the subject ever again or something?Kung-fu Hillbilly wrote: ↑Sat Dec 23, 2023 10:22 pm cambodian-culture-and-language/leave-ma ... 20853.html
It's kinda, like, ya know, helping people.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 41
- Joined: Mon Nov 07, 2016 11:41 pm
- Reputation: 28
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
I remember hearing the news on that incident back then.It was a disaster.Our politicians were so afraid of getting involved in anything in S.E. Asia after Vietnam fell they were hopelessly inept at conducting any military operation in that area.I have been on the sharp end of the stick and almost abandoned by an officer that seemed to have developed the attitude that it is better to do nothing then do something that could turn out wrong.I worked in long range recon and have had officers in the chain of command wait way to long to send support aircraft to extract us and was once told that if the situation is that bad consider the idea of surrender..It really sucks to be left hanging and I can just imagine how terrible the young marines in Koh Tang must have felt when they realized that their officers were unwilling to do what ever was needed to get them out.I spent several years in combat in the Vietnam war and learned that I could not rely on the officers assigned to coordinate our supplies,and aviation support.Some would do what ever was needede to get it done,some wouldn't.The one's that wouldn;t were generally the ones that felt that the current political agenda was more important than the mission.That is what happened to the men who were left behind in KohTang.The overall operation commander on the scene placed his career ahead of his men's lives.Otherwise he would have went back in after them.The upper chain of command is often influenced more by the current political situation than the military situation.I do not hate officers I have known many good ones.However usually the bad ones seem to get into a situation that puts them in the wrong place at the wrong time and they make a mess out of things.The people that left those marines to die were able to retire with full benefits.I know someone who was involved in that mess who was a marine officer at the time.He resigned his commission and left the marine corps after that and went onto the real estate business.He still feels ashamed of our military and our government.
- Earl of Mercia
- Expatriate
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2023 10:21 pm
- Reputation: 49
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
Thanks for the firsthand insight as to what happened in similar scenarios to this,the thing that really gets me is that these poor guys were left in the hands of the bloodthirsty Khmer Rouge,not some occupying army playing by the Geneva Convention?oldfatbarang wrote: ↑Tue Dec 26, 2023 3:55 am I remember hearing the news on that incident back then.It was a disaster.Our politicians were so afraid of getting involved in anything in S.E. Asia after Vietnam fell they were hopelessly inept at conducting any military operation in that area.I have been on the sharp end of the stick and almost abandoned by an officer that seemed to have developed the attitude that it is better to do nothing then do something that could turn out wrong.I worked in long range recon and have had officers in the chain of command wait way to long to send support aircraft to extract us and was once told that if the situation is that bad consider the idea of surrender..It really sucks to be left hanging and I can just imagine how terrible the young marines in Koh Tang must have felt when they realized that their officers were unwilling to do what ever was needed to get them out.I spent several years in combat in the Vietnam war and learned that I could not rely on the officers assigned to coordinate our supplies,and aviation support.Some would do what ever was needede to get it done,some wouldn't.The one's that wouldn;t were generally the ones that felt that the current political agenda was more important than the mission.That is what happened to the men who were left behind in KohTang.The overall operation commander on the scene placed his career ahead of his men's lives.Otherwise he would have went back in after them.The upper chain of command is often influenced more by the current political situation than the military situation.I do not hate officers I have known many good ones.However usually the bad ones seem to get into a situation that puts them in the wrong place at the wrong time and they make a mess out of things.The people that left those marines to die were able to retire with full benefits.I know someone who was involved in that mess who was a marine officer at the time.He resigned his commission and left the marine corps after that and went onto the real estate business.He still feels ashamed of our military and our government.
The American government must have known that their fate was sealed and that they would be summarily executed,yet still chose to stand by and do nothing I just cannot square that circle in my mind imagine how they must have felt knowing quite clearly how they would meet their fateful end?
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 1759
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2016 7:11 am
- Reputation: 357
- Location: Australia
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
Marine motto is to never leave anyone behind. Unfortunately here they did. The exercise was largely political. President Ford needed a win and freeing the ship was seen as a win. I think another 18 Marines died in a helicopter crash in Thailand on the way.
There is a board member who has been there with the body recovery team.
There is a board member who has been there with the body recovery team.
- newkidontheblock
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4467
- Joined: Tue May 20, 2014 3:51 am
- Reputation: 1555
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
Just recently SF forces in Niger were hung out to dry in an operation that went bad.
So unfortunately, the military doesn’t always learn from mistakes.
So unfortunately, the military doesn’t always learn from mistakes.
- Felgerkarb
- Expatriate
- Posts: 801
- Joined: Sun May 18, 2014 7:28 pm
- Reputation: 613
Re: No Man Left Behind-The Mayaguez Incident/Battle of Koh Tang a fascinating story from just after the fall of Saigon 1
Yup.willyhilly wrote: ↑Tue Dec 26, 2023 1:59 pm Marine motto is to never leave anyone behind. Unfortunately here they did. The exercise was largely political. President Ford needed a win and freeing the ship was seen as a win. I think another 18 Marines died in a helicopter crash in Thailand on the way.
There is a board member who has been there with the body recovery team.
===============
We are all puppets in the hands of an insane puppeteer...
--Brother Theodore
We are all puppets in the hands of an insane puppeteer...
--Brother Theodore
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 1 Replies
- 1457 Views
-
Last post by nerdlinger
-
- 3 Replies
- 11634 Views
-
Last post by John Bingham
-
- 3 Replies
- 2392 Views
-
Last post by CEOCambodiaNews
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot], barang_TK, dirtymacca, Doc67, ExPenhMan, KunKhmerSR, Majestic-12 [Bot], Newinkow, NitNoi, Ong Tay and 670 guests