Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

This is where our community discusses almost anything! While we're mainly a Cambodia expat discussion forum and talk about expat life here, we debate about almost everything. Even if you're a tourist passing through Southeast Asia and want to connect with expatriates living and working in Cambodia, this is the first section of our site that you should check out. Our members start their own discussions or post links to other blogs and/or news articles they find interesting and want to chat about. So join in the fun and start new topics, or feel free to comment on anything our community members have already started! We also have some Khmer members here as well, but English is the main language used on CEO. You're welcome to have a look around, and if you decide you want to participate, you can become a part our international expat community by signing up for a free account.
User avatar
John Bingham
Expatriate
Posts: 13767
Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2014 11:26 pm
Reputation: 8973
Cambodia

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by John Bingham »

King Keil wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 2:26 pm you can compare this incident with what would have happened in your hometown in the west.
How likely is it to get beaten with a baton over some minor argument?
It's very easy to get bottled or stabbed in my home city, and it has a lot of areas I wouldn't go near, especially at night.
Silence, exile, and cunning.
User avatar
Kuroneko
Expatriate
Posts: 3809
Joined: Thu May 15, 2014 11:18 am
Reputation: 879

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by Kuroneko »

King Keil wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 2:26 pm A swiss guy got hit with a baton walking his dog over a minor argument. He fell, dropped his head on the pavement and was transported to hospital (Callmette) where they looked at the injuries and sent him home over the night, where he died.
Just an example but you can compare this incident with what would have happened in your hometown in the west.
How likely is it to get beaten with a baton over some minor argument? How likely is it that a hospital sends you home after you heavily hit your head on the pavement in your home country?
You have to take care in cambodia. Things can turn nasty in a heartbeat.
I think you're confusing/altering the facts a bit here!

Swiss Man Died After Argument Over Dogs
On April 24, 2020, at 10:30 pm, the victim and his wife were walking their dog on the river bank. Another dog belonging to the suspect arrived *It’s not quite clear what happened next, but sounds like the dogs might have started fighting.

For some reason the victim took a small metal rod antenna (* maybe an extendable baton or walking stick, unclear), and hit the other man’s dog.

The suspect then hit the victim’s left jaw, who collapsed and then knocked his head. He was taken to Calmette for treatment. After that, the cops arrived and, as indicated by the people at the scene, the police brought the suspect to Central Market Administration for inquiries.

At first, the condition of the victim was unknown, so police sent the suspect home with a warning and the obligation to return another time...............

It was not until the morning of 29 April 2020 at 9:20 that police received information from the victim’s wife via a phone called that her husband had died. Authorities have since detained the suspect to file a court case.[Mod edit: CEO policy is no CNE links please]
King Keil
Expatriate
Posts: 746
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:47 pm
Reputation: 240
Armenia

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by King Keil »

Kuroneko wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 3:23 pm
King Keil wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 2:26 pm A swiss guy got hit with a baton walking his dog over a minor argument. He fell, dropped his head on the pavement and was transported to hospital (Callmette) where they looked at the injuries and sent him home over the night, where he died.
Just an example but you can compare this incident with what would have happened in your hometown in the west.
How likely is it to get beaten with a baton over some minor argument? How likely is it that a hospital sends you home after you heavily hit your head on the pavement in your home country?
You have to take care in cambodia. Things can turn nasty in a heartbeat.
I think you're confusing/altering the facts a bit here!

Swiss Man Died After Argument Over Dogs
On April 24, 2020, at 10:30 pm, the victim and his wife were walking their dog on the river bank. Another dog belonging to the suspect arrived *It’s not quite clear what happened next, but sounds like the dogs might have started fighting.

For some reason the victim took a small metal rod antenna (* maybe an extendable baton or walking stick, unclear), and hit the other man’s dog.

The suspect then hit the victim’s left jaw, who collapsed and then knocked his head. He was taken to Calmette for treatment. After that, the cops arrived and, as indicated by the people at the scene, the police brought the suspect to Central Market Administration for inquiries.

At first, the condition of the victim was unknown, so police sent the suspect home with a warning and the obligation to return another time...............

It was not until the morning of 29 April 2020 at 9:20 that police received information from the victim’s wife via a phone called that her husband had died. Authorities have since detained the suspect to file a court case.[Mod edit: CEO policy is no CNE links please]
Your right it is not really clear what happened. There is a video on facebook where a khmer witness is talking about the incident. Maybe someone who is on facebook can give us more information.
Regardless that area north riverside and wat phnom is not safe at all after 6pm.
User avatar
BklynBoy
Expatriate
Posts: 1255
Joined: Sun Dec 25, 2016 12:11 am
Reputation: 579
United States of America

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by BklynBoy »

I know the dude who punched the guy.. He used to own phily sub house which was right next to Bay Area Tacos in Russian Market.
Manhattan keeps on making it, Brooklyn keeps on taking it
King Keil
Expatriate
Posts: 746
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:47 pm
Reputation: 240
Armenia

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by King Keil »

John Bingham wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 2:31 pm
King Keil wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 2:26 pm you can compare this incident with what would have happened in your hometown in the west.
How likely is it to get beaten with a baton over some minor argument?
It's very easy to get bottled or stabbed in my home city, and it has a lot of areas I wouldn't go near, especially at night.
Just out of curiousity may I ask where you come from. London?
User avatar
Captain Bonez
Baked
Posts: 1173
Joined: Sat Jul 26, 2014 6:44 pm
Reputation: 1111
Location: La-Z-Boy
Nigeria

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by Captain Bonez »

King Keil wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 5:51 pm
John Bingham wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 2:31 pm
King Keil wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 2:26 pm you can compare this incident with what would have happened in your hometown in the west.
How likely is it to get beaten with a baton over some minor argument?
It's very easy to get bottled or stabbed in my home city, and it has a lot of areas I wouldn't go near, especially at night.
Just out of curiousity may I ask where you come from. London?
I've been in average small towns in England on a Friday night where I've had kids that weren't even probably 13 hang out by the ATM with glass bottles trying to intimidate me. I ran into more dickheads and trouble in the UK from the age of around 15 to 23 years old than I have in the last 13 years of living in southeast Asia. Swings and roundabouts
If you enjoy noise pollution and obnoxious driving practices, Phnom Penh is the place for you!

This.
AzalKH
Expatriate
Posts: 78
Joined: Fri May 31, 2019 11:46 pm
Reputation: 50
Great Britain

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by AzalKH »

If you're taking the reasonable precautions you should do in any town/city then overall the place is pretty safe. I've been here 4 years now.

Traffic accidents are definitely the predominant concern. There is a general lack of education and respect, including respecting the fact that even a scooter going at 30kmph will mess someone up if no braking occurs - not to mention a 2 ton SUV going at 60+. Drink driving is very common in PP, my wife won't go any great distance after dark unless we're in the car or taking a taxi (not tuktuk, they fold) for this reason. If you are going out of town then you have to factor in truck drivers who are often on meth to stay awake, I've seen some genuinely terrifying things happen on National Road N4; once we were almost hit from the side by a truck who then avoided us by going into the oncoming lane, where they would have wiped out another truck if he hadn't been attentive and quickly moved into the empty shoulder (a rarity on that road).

Health can be a bit tricky, but there are good doctors here. Certainly not as bad as rexwell suggested, things have evidently improved significantly since 2001... That said many local clinics, aimed at average or poorer Khmer, where doctors will try to get people on saline drips and charge an extortionate amount, sadly many locals seem to buy into it. Worst case Singapore and Thailand are close, look for insurance with emergency evacuation regardless.

As for foreigners dying, I'd put most of that down to age and more importantly substance abuse. It's very easy to overdo alcohol here and obtain over the counter drugs. I've worked at a couple of schools and there were more than a handful of foreigners who drank heavily every single day with others staying in their area. Have seen people bottom out within a couple of weeks on over the counter drugs - Cambodia isn't a place for people who have unresolved problems.

Petty theft is fairly common if you present yourself as a target for opportunists, hand bags or backpacks with easy to break/cut straps aren't recommended in general, and don't step into / too near the street to take a photo or answer your phone. Bike thefts are apparently a big enough thing that my wife always insists I park only in places with attendants, though I've never met anyone who's had their bike stolen myself. It seems no one will try to steal a car though, have seen 100k cars left running with no one in them whilst the owner went for a coffee. Oh, don't go to a seedy massage parlour with $600 in your wallet - this seems to be a recurring problem some expats run into.

Violence towards foreigners is very infrequent. Usually it's more a case of them involving themselves with situations which attract violence, whether that is actual involvement with drug rings, not paying a dealer, messing around with bar girls in the wrong way and getting the bouncers attention; I've seen a guy pretty bloodied in the street after this - though he swore he'd fallen over and hit the curb.

All this said, there is a lot of drama here. If you are able to isolate yourself from it then that's great, though if you are involved with a local then you will be made aware of the goings on in the neighbourhood and there's a higher chance of confrontations related to family.

I could probably write a book on all the bizarre shit that I've experienced here. Though it's not know as the Kingdom of Wonder for nothing. Many of my Khmer friends like to say "The Kingdom of Wonder, it makes you wonder", and they really could not be more right.
User avatar
Marty
BANNED
Posts: 1314
Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2019 7:20 am
Reputation: 344
Canada

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by Marty »

AzalKH wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 9:09 pm If you're taking the reasonable precautions you should do in any town/city then overall the place is pretty safe. I've been here 4 years now.

Traffic accidents are definitely the predominant concern. There is a general lack of education and respect, including respecting the fact that even a scooter going at 30kmph will mess someone up if no braking occurs - not to mention a 2 ton SUV going at 60+. Drink driving is very common in PP, my wife won't go any great distance after dark unless we're in the car or taking a taxi (not tuktuk, they fold) for this reason. If you are going out of town then you have to factor in truck drivers who are often on meth to stay awake, I've seen some genuinely terrifying things happen on National Road N4; once we were almost hit from the side by a truck who then avoided us by going into the oncoming lane, where they would have wiped out another truck if he hadn't been attentive and quickly moved into the empty shoulder (a rarity on that road).

Health can be a bit tricky, but there are good doctors here. Certainly not as bad as rexwell suggested, things have evidently improved significantly since 2001... That said many local clinics, aimed at average or poorer Khmer, where doctors will try to get people on saline drips and charge an extortionate amount, sadly many locals seem to buy into it. Worst case Singapore and Thailand are close, look for insurance with emergency evacuation regardless.

As for foreigners dying, I'd put most of that down to age and more importantly substance abuse. It's very easy to overdo alcohol here and obtain over the counter drugs. I've worked at a couple of schools and there were more than a handful of foreigners who drank heavily every single day with others staying in their area. Have seen people bottom out within a couple of weeks on over the counter drugs - Cambodia isn't a place for people who have unresolved problems.

Petty theft is fairly common if you present yourself as a target for opportunists, hand bags or backpacks with easy to break/cut straps aren't recommended in general, and don't step into / too near the street to take a photo or answer your phone. Bike thefts are apparently a big enough thing that my wife always insists I park only in places with attendants, though I've never met anyone who's had their bike stolen myself. It seems no one will try to steal a car though, have seen 100k cars left running with no one in them whilst the owner went for a coffee. Oh, don't go to a seedy massage parlour with $600 in your wallet - this seems to be a recurring problem some expats run into.

Violence towards foreigners is very infrequent. Usually it's more a case of them involving themselves with situations which attract violence, whether that is actual involvement with drug rings, not paying a dealer, messing around with bar girls in the wrong way and getting the bouncers attention; I've seen a guy pretty bloodied in the street after this - though he swore he'd fallen over and hit the curb.

All this said, there is a lot of drama here. If you are able to isolate yourself from it then that's great, though if you are involved with a local then you will be made aware of the goings on in the neighbourhood and there's a higher chance of confrontations related to family.

I could probably write a book on all the bizarre shit that I've experienced here. Though it's not know as the Kingdom of Wonder for nothing. Many of my Khmer friends like to say "The Kingdom of Wonder, it makes you wonder", and they really could not be more right.
Thank you. This is one of the best assessments ever about the place. Sounds more fun than a barrel of monkeys. Cant wait for air traffic to startup again!
User avatar
fazur
Expatriate
Posts: 994
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2019 11:03 am
Reputation: 358
Norway

Re: Is Phnom Penh Safe compared to other regional cities like Bangkok, HCMC and Hanoi?

Post by fazur »

King Keil wrote: Fri May 01, 2020 4:16 pmRegardless that area north riverside and wat phnom is not safe at all after 6pm.
i run along riverside every day early morning and sometimes late evening have never had trouble

have seen some arguments between locals but never get involved interferes with lap times
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], crackheadyo, DiscoverSEA, Felgerkarb, Freebirdzz, Random Dude, Ryan754326, SINUS and 890 guests