Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13458
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 11:37 pm
- Reputation: 3974
Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
Article from the PPP on kids who work as night-hawkers to support their families : http://www.phnompenhpost.com/post-weeke ... me-hawkers
Anyone who goes out at night sees these kids in the bars and restaurants trying to sell stuff that most people don't really want. Is it better to give them a buck so they finish their night earlier and can go to bed, or do you always stick to the official policy that buying stuff from kids is an encouragement to child exploitation ? Do you give them money to go away or buy them some food ? Has anyone actually called the Childsafe Hotline to report children working at night in the bars of PP or on the beach at SV ?
The article mostly refers to kids who are working for or with their parents, not talking about organized gangs where children are "rented" or used as slaves; but is there a difference if the kids are working directly for their families ?
My theoretical policy is not to buy things from child-hawkers, and that they are all being exploited whether by their family or outsiders. However, I am torn here; I'm not comfortable with this attitude because kids need to eat, by whatever means possible, and yet I am not going to spend every night out looking for a "safe space" for these children. They're not street kids, they have a home and family most of the time, but the adults are not managing to provide for them. I am not an NGO, but I'm not a monster either. Thoughts ?
Anyone who goes out at night sees these kids in the bars and restaurants trying to sell stuff that most people don't really want. Is it better to give them a buck so they finish their night earlier and can go to bed, or do you always stick to the official policy that buying stuff from kids is an encouragement to child exploitation ? Do you give them money to go away or buy them some food ? Has anyone actually called the Childsafe Hotline to report children working at night in the bars of PP or on the beach at SV ?
The article mostly refers to kids who are working for or with their parents, not talking about organized gangs where children are "rented" or used as slaves; but is there a difference if the kids are working directly for their families ?
My theoretical policy is not to buy things from child-hawkers, and that they are all being exploited whether by their family or outsiders. However, I am torn here; I'm not comfortable with this attitude because kids need to eat, by whatever means possible, and yet I am not going to spend every night out looking for a "safe space" for these children. They're not street kids, they have a home and family most of the time, but the adults are not managing to provide for them. I am not an NGO, but I'm not a monster either. Thoughts ?
If approached by a child, Friends International recommends following their Childsafe Movement’s seven tips for travellers and citizens. Those particularly concerned can call their hotline: 012 311 112.
- jaynewcastle
- Expatriate
- Posts: 1150
- Joined: Mon Sep 22, 2014 12:46 am
- Reputation: 342
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
I don't give them anything, and don't speak to them, apart from saying no thank you.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 573
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 12:27 pm
- Reputation: 0
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
The ones entering bars to sell crap should not be encouraged because the idea of letting kids wander about without supervision is terrible.
The ones who are looking after actual market stalls after school are permissible.
The ones who are looking after actual market stalls after school are permissible.
- John Bingham
- Expatriate
- Posts: 13778
- Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2014 11:26 pm
- Reputation: 8975
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
Most are supervised to some extent, their parents are usually nearby. I remember reading that many of the flower sellers are from one village in Kandal province. I wouldn't encourage it, kids shouldn't be going into girly bars late at night. I doubt too many are in dire poverty, they are driven into town on their parent's motos.
Silence, exile, and cunning.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 4267
- Joined: Mon May 19, 2014 1:06 pm
- Reputation: 471
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
Yeah I agree with this.ot mien kampf wrote:The ones entering bars to sell crap should not be encouraged because the idea of letting kids wander about without supervision is terrible.
The ones who are looking after actual market stalls after school are permissible.
Kids should be nowhere near the bars but as you say I think manning a stall after school is ok but they should not be doing this late into the night either.
-
- Expatriate
- Posts: 686
- Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2015 4:09 pm
- Reputation: 0
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
Far bloody worse are the glue-boys - five or six hang around one area of Siem Reap
and whine for alms - one Khmer lady (in Mad Murphy's Irish Bar) says they are
orphanage runaways or chuckouts.
and whine for alms - one Khmer lady (in Mad Murphy's Irish Bar) says they are
orphanage runaways or chuckouts.
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
I don't give money to beggars (children or adults) never and usually I dont buy anything from children. In Cambodia and abroad. i dont want to finance the bee or the smoke of the parents.
But often, when I m not on time pressure I buy some food or give some, when I have with me. Just on the riverside or tourist place I have always to remember not to give food to kids without parents there. Sometime when I have a female friend with me, I gave her money to buy the food for the kids and I stay far away.
I must admit, that when I didnt know about the milk scam in SR I would easily fall in.
I dont think to work for the parents AFTER school and at daylight would be so bad, i did it in Europe too.
But often, when I m not on time pressure I buy some food or give some, when I have with me. Just on the riverside or tourist place I have always to remember not to give food to kids without parents there. Sometime when I have a female friend with me, I gave her money to buy the food for the kids and I stay far away.
I must admit, that when I didnt know about the milk scam in SR I would easily fall in.
I dont think to work for the parents AFTER school and at daylight would be so bad, i did it in Europe too.
- juansweetpotato
- Expatriate
- Posts: 2637
- Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2014 8:45 pm
- Reputation: 75
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
I was told by a Khmer woman that says she knows, that some of the kids begging around 136 in the daytime are sent out by their parents without even any breakfast.They are supposed to beg money and use some of it for breakfast. So, If it is morning I sometimes buy them food, or if they look hungry. The odd thing is that she said she knows of one family who are doing OK but still send their kids out begging.
When I'm eating pork rice on 136 at night and I don't eat it all the kids are very happy to eat it. They are the glue sniffing gang that hang around there most nights it seems. Not sure if they have parents or not. In England many of them do. Cambodia is just one big council estate.
When I'm eating pork rice on 136 at night and I don't eat it all the kids are very happy to eat it. They are the glue sniffing gang that hang around there most nights it seems. Not sure if they have parents or not. In England many of them do. Cambodia is just one big council estate.
"Can you spare some cutter for an old man?"
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
All good people are torn, but your theory is right. Don't give, don't buy. They, children, are only there because some people do.Anchor Moy wrote:My theoretical policy is not to buy things from child-hawkers, and that they are all being exploited whether by their family or outsiders. However, I am torn here...]
I'd like to see a real investigation into where they come from and who they are connected to. I recall the Daily article a few years back claiming they were all (or mostly) there with relatives. I have my doubts. But it needs to be looked into by somebody who has more than a few months in-country/in-region.John Bingham wrote:Most are supervised to some extent, their parents are usually nearby. I remember reading that many of the flower sellers are from one village in Kandal province. I wouldn't encourage it, kids shouldn't be going into girly bars late at night. I doubt too many are in dire poverty, they are driven into town on their parent's motos.
LTO Cambodia Blog
"Kafka is 'outdone' in our country, the new fatherland of Angkor" - Norodom Sihanouk
"Kafka is 'outdone' in our country, the new fatherland of Angkor" - Norodom Sihanouk
- juansweetpotato
- Expatriate
- Posts: 2637
- Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2014 8:45 pm
- Reputation: 75
Re: Child Hawkers Doing the Nightshift - what do you do ?
So, after 30 odd years of aid work, no one knows much about it? That is pretty damning I'd say.LTO wrote: it needs to be looked into by somebody who has more than a few months in-country/in-region.
Is/has there never been an NGO that has focused on street kids? or is there just no money in it?
"Can you spare some cutter for an old man?"
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 2 Replies
- 879 Views
-
Last post by phuketrichard
-
- 46 Replies
- 25317 Views
-
Last post by Phnom Poon
-
- 12 Replies
- 5086 Views
-
Last post by Ot Mean Loi
-
- 3 Replies
- 935 Views
-
Last post by pissontheroof
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: alexvanlaar, Amazon [Bot], Big Daikon, crackheadyo, ExPenhMan, Fourkinnel, John Bingham, Ong Tay, Province, PSD-Kiwi, Soriya, Tywin and 496 guests