Rent or Buy?

Ask us anything. Cambodia Expats Online has a huge community of long-term expats that can answer any question you may have about life in Cambodia. Have some questions you want to ask before you move to Cambodia? Ask them here. Our community can also answer any questions you have about how to find a job or what kind of work is available for expats in Cambodia, whether you're looking for info about Phnom Penh, Siem Reap, or anywhere else in the Kingdom. You're also welcome to ask about visa and work permit questions as well, as the immigration rules change often, especially since COVID-19. Don't be shy, ask CEO's community anything!
User avatar
cptrelentless
Expatriate
Posts: 3033
Joined: Wed Jul 01, 2015 11:49 am
Reputation: 565
Location: Sihanoukville
Korea North

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by cptrelentless »

I think that Taiwanese one on Independence is the one you saw, out of all of them it looks like it might actually get finished. Check back next year sometime
User avatar
Cruisemonkey
Expatriate
Posts: 1162
Joined: Thu Apr 13, 2017 7:16 pm
Reputation: 364
Vietnam

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by Cruisemonkey »

cptrelentless wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 4:02 pm I think that Taiwanese one on Independence is the one you saw, out of all of them it looks like it might actually get finished. Check back next year sometime


This is what I was looking at (thinking of an A-04, A-05 or A-06 unit) -
http://www.sihanoukvilleproperty.com/view-property-922
You could be next.
User avatar
Duncan
Sir Duncan
Posts: 8149
Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:22 pm
Reputation: 2357
Location: Wonder Why Central

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by Duncan »

Cruisemonkey wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 4:23 pm
cptrelentless wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 4:02 pm I think that Taiwanese one on Independence is the one you saw, out of all of them it looks like it might actually get finished. Check back next year sometime


This is what I was looking at (thinking of an A-04, A-05 or A-06 unit) -
http://www.sihanoukvilleproperty.com/view-property-922


Your too late,,, Ask the agent and they will tell you , they are all sold. The only ones that are still available are the small ones with no view. This will be the standed answer where ever you go cause that's the way agents work,,,, by selling the ones no-one wants first. The ones with the view will command a even better price when everything else is sold.
Cambodia,,,, Don't fall in love with her.
Like the spoilt child she is, she will not be happy till she destroys herself from within and breaks your heart.
obelisks
Expatriate
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 15, 2014 5:58 pm
Reputation: 18
Australia

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by obelisks »

Bitte_Kein_Lexus wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 1:57 pm I don't think your comparison is fair Luigi. Housing typically APPRECIATES. I don't get the whole thing of "for every one that makes a profit, another 10 lose"... WTF? As Duncan says, housing has been increasing steadily over the past twenty years... EVERYONE has made money (though in any rising market, after you sell everything else is pricier than it was, of course). As Duncan pointed out, making money is not the exception, it's the rule. How do you think 90% of Khmers invest?

The house I have in the countryside I reckon I could get 1.5 the price I paid if I needed QUICK cash. If I waited out a bit, I could easily double. I built it around 3 years ago... The shophouse I sold two years ago I ended up flush (well, I did make some profit, but nothing insane). I had bought it for $26 000 around 6-8 years ago and sold it for $43 000 minus commission, sangkat etc. At the time I was in desperate need of cash and going through tumultuous times. After I'd sold it (person to person) two of the agencies who had agreed to list it balked when I told them how much I'd sold it for, saying they could have gotten me a lot more had I given them the time and I didn't doubt them. I knew that if I had waited a few months I could have likely gotten 50k+ but I was in a hurry... Oh well. It was a rental so I made some cash of renting it for 5 years or so, plus a bit of appreciation. If I were to sell the current place I live in, I would probably get 1.5X my costs (including the renovations I did). Maybe a bit more if I took my time. I've had this place for roughly 4 years I think, so I've saved something like $12-16 000 in rent on top if it... I remember seeing shophouses by Psah Touyt for $36 000 around 7 years ago. They probably wouldn't sell under $80 000 now. I've never sold a motorbike for MORE than I'd bought it for. Scooters hold their value ok (lose about $100-200 in a weird elliptical curve). All the bigger bikes I've owned I've had to sell at GREAT loss. As in losing 30-40%+. Only one was I able to sell for what I'd bought i for (but I had done a lot of work to it).

Granted, Sihanoukville is quite different and I don't know the market. Phuket posted on the forum a link to someone selling two small houses there by a dirt road for $600 000... I think prices are really inflated in Sihanoukville. Few amenities and services, but there's a premium because the ocean is nearby. I don't get it personally as I hate the place. Plus, rents are very cheap in Sihanoukville. You can get a whole house for very little, and prices are generally low compared to the purchasing price (% wise). And again, I think the important thing is that he's new here and has never lived here full-time. Also, the condo market has exploded so it's all a bit of an unknown at the moment. Might be a good time to get some deals before the election though, but best to wait until late 2018 or so when the OP has a better idea of what he wants to do. I do urge caution and not to buy in December 2018, especially since the guy is retiring I would want a nice and safe place for my cash.
" I don't get the whole thing of "for every one that makes a profit, another 10 lose"... WTF?"

you must be an estate agent to talk like that apparently without any real knowledge of how technology is replacing human labour at a very rapid rate.
and I don't get how you imagine property will keep appreciating when there hasn't been any meaningful budge in salaries and wages for years and there is not likely to be in the future either.. how long can that situation last? Just because property prices increased in the past with central banks printing money to flood the world with fiat currency it doesn'tmean those conditions can prevail in the future?
as more and more pension funds around the world are facing bankruptcy and employment prospects for the next generation look nothing short of bleak who exactly is going to be able to afford to keep bidding up property prices?
User avatar
Bitte_Kein_Lexus
Expatriate
Posts: 4421
Joined: Sun May 18, 2014 7:32 pm
Reputation: 1325

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by Bitte_Kein_Lexus »

Jesus Christ, what are you talking about? We're in Cambodia, not England.
Ex Bitteeinbit/LexusSchmexus
obelisks
Expatriate
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 15, 2014 5:58 pm
Reputation: 18
Australia

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by obelisks »

Bitte_Kein_Lexus wrote: Sun May 14, 2017 8:05 pm Jesus Christ, what are you talking about? We're in Cambodia, not England.
yes a frontier market
rogerrabbit
Expatriate
Posts: 938
Joined: Sat May 14, 2016 1:17 am
Reputation: 347

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by rogerrabbit »

obelisks wrote: Sun May 14, 2017 7:54 pm
Bitte_Kein_Lexus wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 1:57 pm I don't think your comparison is fair Luigi. Housing typically APPRECIATES. I don't get the whole thing of "for every one that makes a profit, another 10 lose"... WTF? As Duncan says, housing has been increasing steadily over the past twenty years... EVERYONE has made money (though in any rising market, after you sell everything else is pricier than it was, of course). As Duncan pointed out, making money is not the exception, it's the rule. How do you think 90% of Khmers invest?

The house I have in the countryside I reckon I could get 1.5 the price I paid if I needed QUICK cash. If I waited out a bit, I could easily double. I built it around 3 years ago... The shophouse I sold two years ago I ended up flush (well, I did make some profit, but nothing insane). I had bought it for $26 000 around 6-8 years ago and sold it for $43 000 minus commission, sangkat etc. At the time I was in desperate need of cash and going through tumultuous times. After I'd sold it (person to person) two of the agencies who had agreed to list it balked when I told them how much I'd sold it for, saying they could have gotten me a lot more had I given them the time and I didn't doubt them. I knew that if I had waited a few months I could have likely gotten 50k+ but I was in a hurry... Oh well. It was a rental so I made some cash of renting it for 5 years or so, plus a bit of appreciation. If I were to sell the current place I live in, I would probably get 1.5X my costs (including the renovations I did). Maybe a bit more if I took my time. I've had this place for roughly 4 years I think, so I've saved something like $12-16 000 in rent on top if it... I remember seeing shophouses by Psah Touyt for $36 000 around 7 years ago. They probably wouldn't sell under $80 000 now. I've never sold a motorbike for MORE than I'd bought it for. Scooters hold their value ok (lose about $100-200 in a weird elliptical curve). All the bigger bikes I've owned I've had to sell at GREAT loss. As in losing 30-40%+. Only one was I able to sell for what I'd bought i for (but I had done a lot of work to it).

Granted, Sihanoukville is quite different and I don't know the market. Phuket posted on the forum a link to someone selling two small houses there by a dirt road for $600 000... I think prices are really inflated in Sihanoukville. Few amenities and services, but there's a premium because the ocean is nearby. I don't get it personally as I hate the place. Plus, rents are very cheap in Sihanoukville. You can get a whole house for very little, and prices are generally low compared to the purchasing price (% wise). And again, I think the important thing is that he's new here and has never lived here full-time. Also, the condo market has exploded so it's all a bit of an unknown at the moment. Might be a good time to get some deals before the election though, but best to wait until late 2018 or so when the OP has a better idea of what he wants to do. I do urge caution and not to buy in December 2018, especially since the guy is retiring I would want a nice and safe place for my cash.
" I don't get the whole thing of "for every one that makes a profit, another 10 lose"... WTF?"

you must be an estate agent to talk like that apparently without any real knowledge of how technology is replacing human labour at a very rapid rate.
and I don't get how you imagine property will keep appreciating when there hasn't been any meaningful budge in salaries and wages for years and there is not likely to be in the future either.. how long can that situation last? Just because property prices increased in the past with central banks printing money to flood the world with fiat currency it doesn'tmean those conditions can prevail in the future?
as more and more pension funds around the world are facing bankruptcy and employment prospects for the next generation look nothing short of bleak who exactly is going to be able to afford to keep bidding up property prices?
Saying salaries haven't raised is not correct. I know multiple young khmers with uni degrees who are working in PP and whose salaries has well over doubled or even tripled in last four years. They are the future middle class and they are "only landed property is the one to buy" generation anymore either.
SinnSisamouth
Expatriate
Posts: 2068
Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2014 1:23 am
Reputation: 8
Ireland

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by SinnSisamouth »

Duncan wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 7:33 pm
Cruisemonkey wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 4:23 pm
cptrelentless wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 4:02 pm I think that Taiwanese one on Independence is the one you saw, out of all of them it looks like it might actually get finished. Check back next year sometime


This is what I was looking at (thinking of an A-04, A-05 or A-06 unit) -
http://www.sihanoukvilleproperty.com/view-property-922


Your too late,,, Ask the agent and they will tell you , they are all sold. The only ones that are still available are the small ones with no view. This will be the standed answer where ever you go cause that's the way agents work,,,, by selling the ones no-one wants first. The ones with the view will command a even better price when everything else is sold.
u contradicted yourself

"The only ones that are still available are the small ones with no view"

"That's the way agents work,,,, by selling the ones no-one wants first"

sounds like u have been burnt a few times so r pretty negative about all land and condo purchasers
i know plenty of barang who have made money on condo or land purchases but then they were not in the Arse end of cam
i am on these blocked lists;
pucketrichard
hotdgr
sailorman
rozzieoz
stroppychops

:fuckyou:
User avatar
Cruisemonkey
Expatriate
Posts: 1162
Joined: Thu Apr 13, 2017 7:16 pm
Reputation: 364
Vietnam

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by Cruisemonkey »

I can see them trying to 'push' the studio units on the backside first. However, if one is emphatic in saying one is not interested I don't believe they wouldn't sell a one-bedroom oceanside given the chance.

It seems PP is already oversupplied with pricey condos and apartments with more and more due to come on the market soon. Undoubtedly, this is at least in part fueled by speculation and foreign, property 'flippers'. The bubble will burst - in a year or so, anyone who's bought may find their unit will only sell for half of what they paid (and it could take a looooong time to sell).

Is the same thing happening in Sooky?

I'm looking for retirement, not to flip for a profit. I'm afraid if I bought a unit, it might end up being in a half empty building where maintenance fees are not being paid - it starts to fall apart, the elevators stop working and the pools are half filled with stagnant rainwater covered in green scum... and my retirement dream turns into a nightmare.
:shock: :shock:
You could be next.
obelisks
Expatriate
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 15, 2014 5:58 pm
Reputation: 18
Australia

Re: Rent or Buy?

Post by obelisks »

rogerrabbit wrote: Sun May 14, 2017 10:22 pm
obelisks wrote: Sun May 14, 2017 7:54 pm
Bitte_Kein_Lexus wrote: Sat May 13, 2017 1:57 pm I don't think your comparison is fair Luigi. Housing typically APPRECIATES. I don't get the whole thing of "for every one that makes a profit, another 10 lose"... WTF? As Duncan says, housing has been increasing steadily over the past twenty years... EVERYONE has made money (though in any rising market, after you sell everything else is pricier than it was, of course). As Duncan pointed out, making money is not the exception, it's the rule. How do you think 90% of Khmers invest?

The house I have in the countryside I reckon I could get 1.5 the price I paid if I needed QUICK cash. If I waited out a bit, I could easily double. I built it around 3 years ago... The shophouse I sold two years ago I ended up flush (well, I did make some profit, but nothing insane). I had bought it for $26 000 around 6-8 years ago and sold it for $43 000 minus commission, sangkat etc. At the time I was in desperate need of cash and going through tumultuous times. After I'd sold it (person to person) two of the agencies who had agreed to list it balked when I told them how much I'd sold it for, saying they could have gotten me a lot more had I given them the time and I didn't doubt them. I knew that if I had waited a few months I could have likely gotten 50k+ but I was in a hurry... Oh well. It was a rental so I made some cash of renting it for 5 years or so, plus a bit of appreciation. If I were to sell the current place I live in, I would probably get 1.5X my costs (including the renovations I did). Maybe a bit more if I took my time. I've had this place for roughly 4 years I think, so I've saved something like $12-16 000 in rent on top if it... I remember seeing shophouses by Psah Touyt for $36 000 around 7 years ago. They probably wouldn't sell under $80 000 now. I've never sold a motorbike for MORE than I'd bought it for. Scooters hold their value ok (lose about $100-200 in a weird elliptical curve). All the bigger bikes I've owned I've had to sell at GREAT loss. As in losing 30-40%+. Only one was I able to sell for what I'd bought i for (but I had done a lot of work to it).

Granted, Sihanoukville is quite different and I don't know the market. Phuket posted on the forum a link to someone selling two small houses there by a dirt road for $600 000... I think prices are really inflated in Sihanoukville. Few amenities and services, but there's a premium because the ocean is nearby. I don't get it personally as I hate the place. Plus, rents are very cheap in Sihanoukville. You can get a whole house for very little, and prices are generally low compared to the purchasing price (% wise). And again, I think the important thing is that he's new here and has never lived here full-time. Also, the condo market has exploded so it's all a bit of an unknown at the moment. Might be a good time to get some deals before the election though, but best to wait until late 2018 or so when the OP has a better idea of what he wants to do. I do urge caution and not to buy in December 2018, especially since the guy is retiring I would want a nice and safe place for my cash.
" I don't get the whole thing of "for every one that makes a profit, another 10 lose"... WTF?"

you must be an estate agent to talk like that apparently without any real knowledge of how technology is replacing human labour at a very rapid rate.
and I don't get how you imagine property will keep appreciating when there hasn't been any meaningful budge in salaries and wages for years and there is not likely to be in the future either.. how long can that situation last? Just because property prices increased in the past with central banks printing money to flood the world with fiat currency it doesn'tmean those conditions can prevail in the future?
as more and more pension funds around the world are facing bankruptcy and employment prospects for the next generation look nothing short of bleak who exactly is going to be able to afford to keep bidding up property prices?
Saying salaries haven't raised is not correct. I know multiple young khmers with uni degrees who are working in PP and whose salaries has well over doubled or even tripled in last four years. They are the future middle class and they are "only landed property is the one to buy" generation anymore either.
Didn’t you notice I used the words “meaningful budge in salaries and wages for years “
Firstly how many “multiple young khmers with uni degrees “are there out there exactly who are earning any more than $2500 per month ( even if that much) and even then what would be the extent of their purchasing power? And if all these multiple young Khmers decide to buy a condominium, would they still be able to get even close to absorbing the almost 20,000 units that will swell the Phnom Penh supply by 2018? This is an increase of 915% .


This article also states “Supply and demand based on real homebuyers remains tilted towards the speculative high end, and “this will lead to a lot of empty condos in the future,”

On this basis I would be genuinely interested to learn how property can keep " typically appreciating " with such a huge looming oversupply- or don’t economic supply and demand laws apply in Cambodia? :roll:

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/real-estat ... ndo-market
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Clutch Cargo, Deefer, khmerhamster, Ong Tay, ron100, Semrush [Bot], Tootsfriend and 321 guests